Immigration - We Must Secure Our Borders!

Related Issues: Homeland Security , Immigration Policy , Illegal Immigration , Border Security

Tags: immigration illegal , immigration reform

Tuesday, 03/25/2008 @ 02:55 PM

To whom it may concern:

I'm writing regarding the illegal immigration situation. Some people refer to it as "immigration reform," but I refer to it as national security.

In 1951 President Eisenhower addressed the problem of some 3 million illegals walking into the USA. He did it quickly and decisively with only 1,075 United States Border Patrol agents. His solution was to address the ethical standards of border officials, emoving many in Texas, California, Arizona and other areas who had been entrenched in their jobs for years.

As a concerned citizen I'm tired of all the round about discussion about necessary workers, human rights, families and other diversions used to deflect the central discussion. That central discussion is security and the law. While it's great to be concerned with the well being of others, that concern does not and should not trump concern over laws. People who break a basic law like entering the nation won't have concern for other laws, or for the nation as a whole and the laws of this society.

It's time to stop discussions and start taking action. Secure the borders, stop the influx of illegals. This must be done before and regardless of any other reforms. Address the businesses that hire illegals with heavy fines and other penalties that remove the benefit of hiring workers who are exempt from minimum wage, benefits, and other employment laws. Address the illegals who are in this country by penalizing them with immediate deportation if and when they're caught.

The Constitution does not guarantee people rights gained as a result of breaking laws, and no moral principle demands that. In fact, it's a disservice to illegals to not expect them to follow the same laws followed by legal citizens and residents as if the illegals are somehow sub-human or unable to comply. It's a disservice to illegals to treat them as a near slave labor class earning less than others earn by law.

Senator, I urge you to work to address this situation. I urge it not only for the good of the country, and for the good of the immigrants, but also for your own good. Your constituents will not stand for this situation, and it will impact you in the voting booth.

Hopeful,

fcabanski

Total Comments: 157

Write your own comment on this letter!

	Katya, on 03/25/2008 @ 03:08 PM wrote:
		It's not just Mexican immigrants that I am concerned with walking across the porous border. Many migrants contribute much to this country; working in agriculture, service and hospitality industries. What is of greater concern are the Pakistanis and other identified terrorist host countries' immigrants that enter through Canada as well as Mexico. Many are caught, detained briefly and then released with the promise to return at a specified court date. You know how many return? Very, very few. Our border security is a mess.

	fcabanski, on 03/25/2008 @ 07:58 PM wrote:
		Whether they contribute or not, if they entered illegally it is a problem. I agree that illegals from anywhere are a concern. If someone breaks into your home but mops the floor, you're still going to call the police.

	DrkJedi, on 03/26/2008 @ 04:30 PM wrote:
		This is so true and well written. I agree with everything that you said in your letter as well as your comment. It is not only Mexican immigrants, it is all people who enter this country illegally. Stop the talking and secure the border!

	JM4Change, on 03/26/2008 @ 09:46 PM wrote:
		I agree with securing the borders and the legal expectation. Regarding wages, I respectfully disagree. I think we should allow controlled numbers of migrant workers with a separate set of wage regulations. They are coming here because they make more money than in Mexico, so I don't see how it is a disservice to them to pay them less than Americans. Is it more of a service to force them to stay in Mexico and earn a fraction of that pay? No. It is a win-win situation to allow controlled numbers to provide what is to us cheap labor, for what is to them great wages.

	fcabanski, on 03/26/2008 @ 11:14 PM wrote:
		It's a disservice to both the immigrants, even if they were legal, and to citizens. It's a disservice to them to bring them into America but pay them less than the going wage in America. That's a slave class. It's a disservice to Americans to have to compete with people who can legally be paid less.

	JDog, on 03/27/2008 @ 11:00 AM wrote:
		Is there anyone (other than those sneaking across) not wanting to secure our borders? I would be surprised if this were the case. Which makes me ask another question. Why AREN'T we securing our borders?

	Stephenuys, on 03/27/2008 @ 01:46 PM wrote:
		The last major secured border in Modern times was the Soviet Union. Their draconian measures sure got them far. By our borders, most people are refferring to our Southern Border. Crack-pot fear -mongering has replaced common sense. Physical walls, electronic monitoring, dogs, and an army of amped up legalized minutemen. Who do we want the world to think we are? I agree that some system of visas or temporary permits should be enforcrd. We are a land built on immigrants, and need to remain one. Additionally, not one member of Al quaida has been caught crossing our southern border. It is dangerous nationalism, coupled with racism, that is fuelling this debate. We need strict controls, not isolationist fear mongering. Stephenuys.

	JM4Change, on 03/27/2008 @ 04:37 PM wrote:
		How is it a "slave class"? Slavery means people being the property of other people... not even close to the same thing. This is an agreed business transaction that is a benefit to the migrant worker who makes MORE money than he would have at home. It benefits the economy because there is a relatively cheap labor pool boosting our GDP. Farmers don't have to compete with other employers for workers willing to do backbreaking labor, which would cause them to have to pay much more and hence drive produce prices through the roof for everyone. We need these workers. As every great society has had a source of cheap labor, we should sustain ours for our own good. It is not a disservice to them, because they are not citizens!!! We are giving them a choice to enter our country to make more money for their families! Why should we pay non-citizens according to our minimum wage, when they don't live here?? They are coming to make money and wouldn't come if it wasn't to their benefit.

	ryan, on 03/28/2008 @ 09:24 AM wrote:
		I agree with this letter. JM4Change - So what minimum wage would you set for this "cheap labor pool?" Have you asked yourself where will these people live, get healthcare, or go to school. Will you require them to have their own healthcare as they are currently draining our healthcare system dry? You state that they are not living here which is totally false. They are living here, most of the time, multiple families in one house, driving without a license and insurance, and costing our governments billions of dollars annually. Finally, taking advantage of a migrant worker because he would make more money than in his/her own country is reprehensible. This would not just stop at the farmers; hotel operators, restaurants would hire the "cheap labor pool" and displace workers that are here legally. Close the borders and punish employers who hire illegal immigrants.

	Johnny5000, on 03/28/2008 @ 08:45 PM wrote:
		I would have to agree with Ryan, JM4Change. It's one thing to bring in migrant workers for agricultural work, but make the employer pay a fair wage (and tax both the employer and the worker on it). We're getting hit with a double whammy here - no tax income from the employer / worker and a tax drain in the form of free services to the worker. This has got to stop.

	JM4Change, on 03/29/2008 @ 09:35 AM wrote:
		The tax argument is old hat and oversimplifies the issue. While there are certain costs to the taxpayer, I contend that the benefit to the economy exceeds this relatively small tax cost (compared to military, criminal justice, etc). Without cheap labor for menial jobs, these low margin employers are forced to compete for American workers, who do not want to do this job even for a minimum wage. Thus, wages are driven up, driving up business costs and prices for consumers, and forcing business owners to downsize. It would be a huge negative hit to the economy that far exceeds the cost. Your reasons for wanting immigrants gone are all over the place. Do you want them gone because it is "a disservice" to give them a job that improves their quality of life, or because they supposedly hurt our economy? I have to wonder if there is another motive here.

	ryan, on 03/29/2008 @ 03:18 PM wrote:
		I have not said that I want illegal immigrants gone and should not be allowed back in the U.S. They should be given a few months to get things in order here in the U.S. then be forced to return to their home country. Once back in Mexico they can go through the proper channels to get a work visa to be here legally. If there was more need in particular jobs, such as agriculture, the government can increase the number of work visas temporarily to offset the demand. Additionally, Paying minimum wage, and the respective taxes, will not force the price of lettuce or tomatoes to sky rocket. We shouldn't turn a blind eye to the fact that millions of people are here illegally and using government provided services simply for the mere fact we might pay a few cents more per pound for items such as vegetables and fruit.

	JM4Change, on 03/30/2008 @ 12:00 PM wrote:
		Ryan, then perhaps you and I are not so far off. My original comment says that we do need to crack down on illegal immigration, but we should develop a good migrant worker program through which we can optimize the number of workers allowed to be here on temporary visas. Illegal immigration is less than ideal because of its inequity to those who use legal channels, and our inability to control the numbers.

	askunk, on 04/01/2008 @ 06:43 PM wrote:
		How do you propose the issue of those already in the country, who are not caught, be handled? If current illegal immigrants are legalized, then they will have to pay taxes and be required to have car insurance. By doing those things, the government will be showing that they do not want to treat illegal immigrants as a slave labor class.

	taunate, on 04/02/2008 @ 12:04 AM wrote:
		I am all for an immigrant coming to America and doing it legally so they can live their dream. But realisticly there will always be an illegal immigrant problem. Its just not possible to cover all corners.

	SacMom, on 04/02/2008 @ 08:47 AM wrote:
		I think every country needs to protect their borders. I think in this country we have waited too long and done to little about it. It's never too late to make a change though.

	halliseym, on 04/02/2008 @ 04:33 PM wrote:
		I think every country needs to protect their borders. I think our country has hugely overpopulated in many areas because of immagrants. LOCK THEM OUT! Why should we have to learn languages to speak to people coming to AMERICA, where we speak ENGLISH.

	mruby, on 04/03/2008 @ 12:45 PM wrote:
		Definitly tis is problem. I all for legal immigration. Everyone must follow the rules.

	kissmekate, on 04/03/2008 @ 01:30 PM wrote:
		I think the government needs to make it easier and cheaper for Mexicans to become US citizens. If you put yourself in their shoes, you would find that they are just trying to make a better life for themselves and their families. I know if I lived there in poverty, I would make a run for the border to give my kids a better life. Not only that, but they are extrememly hard working... they take the worst jobs that don't pay anything.

	Kazuar, on 04/03/2008 @ 03:09 PM wrote:
		America is an immigrant nation. While illegal immigration's a problem and the law must be upheld there, we should be looking to make these people citizens and integrate them into American society, or to make legal immigration easier.

	autumn_blaze, on 04/03/2008 @ 11:12 PM wrote:
		I think that illegal migrants raises the issue of the security of our borders. If migrants can ebter, then so can terrorists.

	bennyboy5768, on 04/04/2008 @ 05:57 PM wrote:
		I agree. On most parts of the border, it simply just a broken fence allowing anyone to walk over. Many may be looking for a new life and thats great but everyone should go through the proper procedure.

	itzjoeymac, on 04/05/2008 @ 08:49 AM wrote:
		We absolutely must do something about all these illegals. They are taking jobs that Americans should be doing. We could probably get rid welfare if the unemployed were required to take the jobs immigrants now have.

	jp1999, on 04/05/2008 @ 12:19 PM wrote:
		I agree. What is wrong with people coming here legally? I mean really.

	starmode6, on 04/07/2008 @ 10:34 AM wrote:
		I don't think securing the border is the way to go, we need to come up with a better education program so immigrates can work on becoming legal, or an easier process so they don't have to illegally cross the border.

	SOLOWPOET, on 04/07/2008 @ 08:29 PM wrote:
		our borders need to be protected if you want to stay in this country take the proper steps to do so!

	purplelaurii77, on 04/08/2008 @ 11:02 AM wrote:
		Let us not forget that the illegals coming in are often looking for a better way of life. In the meantime there are millions in America that are without jobs and adequate housing. I have heard the argument that they come and take away only jobs that the Americans would not lower themselves to do. Is it because at the wages the companies can pay these people an American citizen can not survive? If the wages were higher I believe all jobs would be filled.

	Liquid88, on 04/08/2008 @ 01:02 PM wrote:
		I agree with parts of your letter. However I think that several different countries could pose threats to us by crossing our border so I definitely think security should be tightened up majorly.

	hought41, on 04/08/2008 @ 02:01 PM wrote:
		We are already loosing enough jobs to outsourcing. Now the borders are basically allowing illegal imigrants to outsource themselves by coming to the US, working and taking legal americans jobs.

	hollyoswalt, on 04/08/2008 @ 02:27 PM wrote:
		I agree our borders need to be more secure. Illegals in this country use our resources without paying for them in the form of taxes. Food stamps, for example, is one that really irks me. If they want to come to this country, by all means, come; but do it legally!

	jazy716, on 04/08/2008 @ 07:51 PM wrote:
		Everyone in the country is governed by the same laws. Being illegal means you have committed a crime and should be punished.

	ilovemeeps2, on 04/08/2008 @ 07:58 PM wrote:
		By being friends with the immigrant community, I know that they are hard workers who gain no economic government benefits from being in this country. Remember that if they were legal, many of them would receive money back from the government because they take the jobs that pay low and not many people want.

	Megalomaniac, on 04/09/2008 @ 01:39 AM wrote:
		I agree we should put all illegal imigrants to death for breaking the laws of this great country... The best way to do it is to sub-contract some illegals(that way we wont go to jail for murder) to kill other illegals and promise them they will indeed stay in this great country. After they kill the illegals they will eventually get arrested and deported or better yet, imprisoned. <making us keep our promise. In less than a month I garantee that most if not all illegals will be gone... LOL... ..X...

	annielouwho, on 04/09/2008 @ 10:13 AM wrote:
		All immigrants, from all foreign countries, should be held to the same standards. None should be rewarded for coming here illegally and none should be exempt from going through the channels already established. If we continue to give our country away, people will continue to bleed us dry.

	RandyAggie, on 04/09/2008 @ 11:54 PM wrote:
		Not only are our borders not nearly secure enough, but we do not have harsh enough punishments for those who are found here. We allow them to march waving the flags of their home country demanding equal treatment. Disgusting!

	Bracholi, on 04/10/2008 @ 07:08 AM wrote:
		If I remember correctly... and I do from my family history... When my relatives came here from Russia they didn't know English. They made it a priority to learn English and demanded NO special treatment.

	amwarner71, on 04/10/2008 @ 01:09 PM wrote:
		I too agree with Katya it's not only the Mexican that we should worry about. It's all the others that can pose a more threat to us.

	SOLOMON504, on 04/10/2008 @ 08:14 PM wrote:
		WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE SATISFIED UNTIL WE WAKE UP IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT TO SOMETHING REALLY BAD GOING DOWN......SECURE OUR BORDERS

	QueenOfTheCarnival, on 04/10/2008 @ 09:43 PM wrote:
		Thank you for writing this letter. It's refreshing to hear real US citizens that really care for our country and know whats going on.

	nubsnovets, on 04/10/2008 @ 10:28 PM wrote:
		I'm sorry to inform you but our borders will never be secure. In 2005 talks began about a North American Union. I'm sure you have heard of the European union. Same thing. So, instead of tighter security there will be no more borders. People can enter our country from Mexico without any problems. The REAL ID act that was passed back in 2005 is now trying to force us to have a national ID instead of a state license. This is all so hush hush because they don't want a riot on their hands. But this information is true. Bush had met with the leader of Mexico back in 2005 and I have even seen an interview with the Mexican president. He talks about the new money that will be created to replace our money. The new money will be called the Aero. Don't believe me then do a search for yourself.

	Roberto, on 04/10/2008 @ 10:31 PM wrote:
		fcabaski, why would you wanna say such a things when we don't have enough human resource ourself, yet our economy largely rely on the immigrants on certain sectors . And yeh theres always a better way in dealing with illegal immigration then to drive them back.

	Alandale, on 04/11/2008 @ 02:26 AM wrote:
		No. I think we should just all pack up and leave it here for the immagrints every hundred years. How would that be! Its like we had our chance now its your turn in the promised land.

	carlyc07, on 04/11/2008 @ 11:22 AM wrote:
		Your letter is so true. We need to stop illegals from entering our country for our own safety. Our well being as American citizens should not be trumped by the lazy attitude of lawmakers who do nothing about it.

	MotherGrizzly, on 04/11/2008 @ 11:54 AM wrote:
		I concur; my husband is Canadian and we paid a lot of money to immigration to do things RIGHT. He did not "sneak in" to this country and has a legal Green Card as a result of our efforts. We need to clean up border security; we will always be open to threats if we continue in this vein.

	den23, on 04/11/2008 @ 02:26 PM wrote:
		God damned fence hoppers need to be taught a lesson, Yessir. Who's that an impression of, you Republican b@stard?

	den23, on 04/11/2008 @ 02:28 PM wrote:
		Just writing this comment so I can engage the "comment alert" feature

	joey2dworld, on 04/12/2008 @ 05:49 AM wrote:
		You said it! Something has got to be done and obviously, the best to rid our actual citizens of unemployment is to have them working the jobs the aliens now have.

	grickabaugh, on 04/12/2008 @ 10:53 AM wrote:
		I agree. My frustration is for those who are trying to enter the country legally. How do you feel when you are standing in line somewhere, and someone cuts in line? Fortunately, the wall is going up now and that should help. But we should learn a lesson from Arizona and crack down on employers who knowingly hire illegal immigrants.

	mommajones, on 04/12/2008 @ 07:57 PM wrote:
		You are exactly right. Something needs to be done about the illegal immigrant situation. Too many people think that it is easy to come to America, which in turn, makes people think they have "rights" when they get here. However, if you break a law to get here, then how does that give you any rights? To recieve rights in America you have to be a CITIZEN of America. So why are all these immigrants recieving rights, when they don't pay taxes or follow the laws like all the rest of us.

	LauraMae, on 04/12/2008 @ 11:48 PM wrote:
		I agree. Of all the borders we should be "protecting", our own borders should have priority.

	mwnoble, on 04/13/2008 @ 06:39 AM wrote:
		Of Course we need to secure our borders! Immigrant workers are another issue altogether that needs it's now attention.

	phmcd, on 04/13/2008 @ 08:31 AM wrote:
		Some of it is true. We need to secure the borders but also allow foreign nationals to enter and work. Our economy depends on the Mexican worker.

	ramone_hamilton, on 04/13/2008 @ 10:38 AM wrote:
		Illegal immigration is very bad problem and despite what people say, does not only include immigrants south of the border, but immigrants abroad also.

	aquafitz, on 04/13/2008 @ 07:40 PM wrote:
		I agree that illegal immigration is a problem, but securing our borders isn't enough. The process of naturalisation should be made less stringent; after all, how many US-born citizens are actually able to pass the naturalisation test? By lowering the standards for citizenship, we can help mitigate this problem of illegal immigration.

	ninjanana15, on 04/13/2008 @ 07:45 PM wrote:
		I think our government should take more action to secure our borders.

	karenkpc, on 04/13/2008 @ 11:20 PM wrote:
		I would love to see the borders secured properly, although I do understand the cost of maintaining that kind of security. Well done on this letter!

	moodysg, on 04/14/2008 @ 01:30 AM wrote:
		Admittedly there is a problem when it comes to immigration. Tightening border security, however, is not the solution. Regardless of how tight security is, illegal immigrants will come to America. If security is tightened and the illegal population of America is decreased, the demand for illegal labor will rise and people will go to extreme lengths to immigrate. This will lead to nothing more than dangerous attempts and jails crowded with, not terrorists, but destitute immigrants trying to support their families. You are thinking in the complete opposite direction. By making it easier to immigrate you guarantee rights for more workers and thereby equalize the job market.

	melkisedeh, on 04/14/2008 @ 08:11 AM wrote:
		We must secure the borders. It cost all of us more paying for all illegal immigrants than building a fence 30 feet high on all the Mexican border!

	twagles, on 04/14/2008 @ 05:50 PM wrote:
		You guise your argument in the cloak of "national security" but really, how many terrorist attacks have been perpetrated by illegals? Are there roving gangs of illegals burning towns and looting? No, the 9/11 hijackers had visas. There is no security threat and claiming there is is nothing more than scaremongering.

	TLHE, on 04/14/2008 @ 07:24 PM wrote:
		While I agree that we shouldn't encourage or reward people for entering the country illegally I think your view on the situation is disgusting and misguided. Most illegal immigrants are motivated and hard working. To insinuate that they're all criminals bound to break our laws while they live here just because they broke them in order to enter the country is ludicrous. Anyway, don't you think if they were all going around peddling crack that they'd be caught and deported a lot quicker? Yes! Which is why they work at Mc Donalds.

	Markahorn, on 04/14/2008 @ 07:40 PM wrote:
		I like people who spend so much time telling others what to do. When you have personally expelled 20 illegals call me and i help you. Until then you comments are meaningless.

	Svenlol, on 04/14/2008 @ 10:56 PM wrote:
		If everyone who commits a crime goes punished, the jails would be more overflowing than they are already. These immigrants are trying to make a living, not trying to steal yours.

	Svenlol, on 04/14/2008 @ 10:56 PM wrote:
		If everyone who commits a crime goes punished, the jails would be more overflowing than they are already. These immigrants are trying to make a living, not trying to steal yours.

	shanaeb, on 04/15/2008 @ 07:21 AM wrote:
		I totally agree with you, I also believe that there is something that the most powerful country "America" can do about it. This should not even be an issue it's 2008.

	sticktango, on 04/15/2008 @ 09:54 AM wrote:
		I agree that we changes need to be made in immigration regulation. But, I don't think that closing our borders is the way to go.

	k229, on 04/15/2008 @ 01:01 PM wrote:
		Illegal immigration must be stopped. Its a slap in the face of legal immigrants who have done everything necessary to enter this country.

	FastLane8, on 04/15/2008 @ 01:30 PM wrote:
		Those Republican senators are taking good care of their corporate friends and that means the number of illegals coming in has skyrocketed to over 15 million. Of course, the bottom line and stock prices have also skyrocketed on their watch with cheap labor. They won't fix anything. You must be dreaming.

	funkedog, on 04/15/2008 @ 07:42 PM wrote:
		Immigration is a huge issue in Amercian politics right now, WIth our economy on such shaky ground, out leaders need to take a good look at how this is handled.

	spritelylite, on 04/15/2008 @ 08:10 PM wrote:
		Our current immigration freak-out shows me just how backward this country still is. We are a nation built by immigrants.

	glublahh, on 04/16/2008 @ 05:22 AM wrote:
		This is an irrational fear, immigrants should be welcomed, helped and made to feel at home within our borders. I agree that underpaying slave-like jobs are not the way to go, but dont make it seem like your doing them a favour by not letting them in, many are "dying" to leave their motherlands and live a pleasantville life.

	littlered, on 04/16/2008 @ 11:56 AM wrote:
		This letter hits home for me. I agree completely. The illegal immigrant problem in this country is beyond out of control. What's worse is that these illegals are still getting Tax ID Numbers so that they can PAY TAXES. Not here legally, but the government sure doesn't care, so long as they get their money. And they wonder how Sept. 11th happened. These guys are getting free reign of whatever they want once they get here. Build a fence - a REALLY BIG fence.

	Conti45, on 04/16/2008 @ 05:14 PM wrote:
		Not only should we stop the immigrants at the border we should send away the illegal immigrants that are here already. It's time to round up the British, French, Spanish and every other illegal immigrant or illegal immigrant descendant that can't show proof of legal immigration according to native American laws. It's time to stand up for native American nations, arrest the "illegals" and send them back to where they came from.

	usmama25, on 04/16/2008 @ 05:39 PM wrote:
		I must say, although I am torn on this subject, you cannot just say fine all of the companies that use illegal aliens. Do you know how fast businesses would go out of business, or how much more we would be paying for services? America has always found a way to get "cheap labor" and will continue to do so as long as we are a capitalistic society.

	janesmith222, on 04/17/2008 @ 10:52 PM wrote:
		I agree immigration is a situation that needs to be addresssed as soon as possible.

	nateman10, on 04/18/2008 @ 10:07 PM wrote:
		The word "illegal says it all. No illegal activities should ever have be allowed to continue. Either action must be taken, or the law must be changed.

	AJChambers, on 04/18/2008 @ 10:34 PM wrote:
		Or perhaps that illegals would choose America over their own country would show that they're interested in bettering their lives through work?

	samand, on 04/19/2008 @ 10:52 AM wrote:
		You're absolutely right we just can't let random people wander across our borders. I know people who have tried to come over here legally and they were rejected, meanwhile we don't even know how many people filter in across the border on an hourly basis. Why even have borders if you're not going to uphold them? Maybe we just shouldn't have borders at all huh.

	familyman, on 04/19/2008 @ 12:11 PM wrote:
		First we need to create a more severe penalty for employers, if they didn't hire illegal immigrants, it wouldn't be as attractive for them to enter illegally. Another problem I have is coming here to have babies, and then the child is automatically a citizen. What is the benefit to anyone other than the illegal entrant?

	familyman, on 04/19/2008 @ 02:08 PM wrote:
		It is pathetic that we created more government (Homeland Security) but yet we still let anyone who wants to enter this country through our borders!

	tmthomp3, on 04/20/2008 @ 09:46 AM wrote:
		I agree with you! I just wonder when our constitutional right began to be guranteed to non-citizens of this country. it seems that the immigrants are making a better life here because our governement and other agencies provide them with more assistance than we do those of us guarantee this help under our law. It's time to begin charity at home!

	Zenarchist, on 04/20/2008 @ 10:30 AM wrote:
		If we would stop running around the world making everyone hate us, there wouldn't be much need for secure borders. But then again, I am confused why I have a right to a land I do not own over someone else simply because I was born there.

	msjbelle, on 04/20/2008 @ 12:43 PM wrote:
		This is a well written letter. I agree whole heartedly. We have enough of our own issues to support illegal immigrants.

	amiz, on 04/20/2008 @ 03:26 PM wrote:
		I think that we tend to forget that there is a border to our north (which by the way is over twice as long and has far fewer agents patrolling).

	nimasam, on 04/20/2008 @ 06:25 PM wrote:
		it can be very big security concern and shoudl be addressed asap.

	mgill87, on 04/20/2008 @ 06:25 PM wrote:
		I'm scared by all these people wanting a fence. This fence will be used to keep Americans in the country. Combined with a national ID card that records your ethnicity, I could easily see genocide occuring here.

	japhy4529, on 04/20/2008 @ 08:18 PM wrote:
		This situation does truly come down to a legal issue. People are crossing the border illegally, and the government needs to find a way that works. More border patrol agents would be nice, however, I think that economic incentives to Mexico would go a long way in helping out our neighbors to the south get jobs (or better jobs), which would decrease the need to come to this country illegally.

	Shalor87, on 04/20/2008 @ 09:01 PM wrote:
		With the state of our National Security being as it is, I can't believe we're still allowing aliens to just come on in. I'm proud of the fact that I live in a county that offers the freedom that so many others would love to have and I'd like to protect it. I think we need to set up better systems so that immigrants can legally enter the US and then be monitored while they're here to ensure that they're following our laws and taking the steps to become citizens. I agree 100% with large fines for any business hiring illegals.

	DeadGrrl, on 04/20/2008 @ 10:06 PM wrote:
		If we build a wall we also need to add a door. by this i mean that if we are going to make it harder to come into the U.S illegally, then we should make it easier to come legally. This is coming from a caucasian girl who lives in a highly mexican populated area of Phoenix AZ.

	steveiller, on 04/20/2008 @ 10:22 PM wrote:
		I agree with all the points of your article and something needs to be done now about this problem

	polaris23, on 04/21/2008 @ 01:52 AM wrote:
		I would like to see more precautions regarding the border as well. It is apparently been in talks to rid ourselves of the borders of mexico and canada, I feel this could be america's biggest mistake.

	magikid, on 04/22/2008 @ 06:53 PM wrote:
		The main problem I have with illegal immigrants is not that they are taking jobs from Americans (cause they aren't), it's the fact that they refuse to learn English.

	cmhdom31, on 04/23/2008 @ 09:03 PM wrote:
		You make such a good point and immigration is a great concern of mine as well. We need to do something about this and quickly. Your point about fining the businesses that hire the illegals is a great one this needs to be done. I hope something will be done. cmhdom31

	Brianetics, on 04/24/2008 @ 11:23 PM wrote:
		I agree that illegal immigration is something to be concerned about but I don't think a wall is the way to go. Perhaps the whole system is broke and needs an overhaul so that those that deserve to be here can do so more easily while the undesirables are kept out.

	Cangel, on 04/25/2008 @ 11:32 AM wrote:
		I totally agree that, as my parents and grandparents waited for their turn and "earned" the chance to come to America, so should people today.

	samantha_scott30, on 04/25/2008 @ 11:46 PM wrote:
		Have you forgotten that illegal aliens provide the bulk of low-paid manual labor (think maids, farm labor, construction work, factory work, etc.) that American citizens consider themselves "above"? We reap the benefits of illegal aliens' labor every single day of our lives. Yet, we still demonize and demean these hardworking individuals. It's utter hypocrisy.

	qtkleee151, on 04/26/2008 @ 07:54 AM wrote:
		I believe everyone should have to legally enter this country, why is it fair that some people enter legally and others enter illegally with not punishment?

	LouisZ03, on 04/27/2008 @ 09:12 AM wrote:
		It is absolutely necessary to secure our borders. The border with Mexico seems to be falling apart with more and more illegal aliens seeping through every day. I don't know if a fence will help, but I really can't see how it would hurt.

	ZaLyd, on 04/28/2008 @ 08:31 AM wrote:
		The key part to remember is "illegal" alien. These people have no regard for our laws, but want our jobs, our social security, and our federal and state support. Our country will never be safe as long as the states protect the illegal aliens.

	rejuvantedone, on 04/28/2008 @ 03:51 PM wrote:
		i agree as well it can be a problem, however, every person should have a chance to live in america and live their dream. If they break the law they'll pay the price by going to jail. Not all of them are bad, there are some that work their asses off for less money than most of us make. They value a dollar alot more than we do. We should learn from them.

	kararobinette, on 04/29/2008 @ 09:16 PM wrote:
		I agree with you completely. America holds its arms out and welcomes so many immigrants but this transition needs to do lawfully and if they want to be Americans they need to adhere to the same standards we do as citizens. They deserve to be treated just as we are. And businesses who feel they are above this should be punished.

	master_chief, on 04/29/2008 @ 10:02 PM wrote:
		it is sad to say, but it is impossible. our border is too great, it would be an enormous drain on our economy to not only secure the mexican border, but also the canadian border. Illegal immigrants pay income tax and do not recieve rebates, so they actually help to fund the government. their constant influx also helps balance out the US population decline. without that our economy would start to go downhill. (oh wait, it already is)

	EliciaM, on 04/30/2008 @ 09:00 AM wrote:
		Our borders need to be secured. It is ungraceful to allow immigrants into our country to act like slaves. This needs to stop and the only way to do is by securing our borders. They need to take action and quit talking about what actions they are going to take.

	dab290, on 04/30/2008 @ 07:35 PM wrote:
		Illegal immigration. How can anyone defend something that has illegal in the name? I mean, it's a no-brainer to me, but apparently the democrats would like the extra few million votes..

	j2n2, on 05/01/2008 @ 07:27 AM wrote:
		"People who break a basic law... won't have concern for other laws, or for the nation as a whole..." This pretty much sums up every politician who might actually be able to address the issue of immigration. It's sad, but the immigration issue is not about to get better for Americans. Illegal immigrants will continue to flood our communities, and our government will continue to allow it because they don't really care. If they cared, it wouldn't be that difficult to resolve.

	griffy, on 05/01/2008 @ 11:59 AM wrote:
		Illegals undercut our wages and are willing to work for paltry amounts. It's wrong and is not helping our country

	Lucretia722, on 05/02/2008 @ 12:20 AM wrote:
		Not only are we too concerned with the rights of non-citizens v.s. U.S. citizens, but we also give them more assistane than our own. Every deserves a fair shot...how is sneakin in fair?

	missna, on 05/02/2008 @ 09:30 AM wrote:
		The U.s. spends far too much time with the issues of immigrants what happened to putting the needs of our citizens first.

	lauriej, on 05/02/2008 @ 09:47 PM wrote:
		Are you forgetting that at some point all of us or our parents, grand parents . . .etc. were immigrants? If the governemnt had tried to stop immigration 100 years ago you probably wouldn't be living here.

	Cammeel1, on 05/03/2008 @ 02:54 PM wrote:
		Sure I have feelings for someone who wishes to cross into our country because they cannot find clean water in their own. However, we are in debt quite enough! Jobs here are scarce enough as it is without an immigrant offering to do the work for a fraction of the cost. Besides national security is more important than ever before. We have to protect ourselves or we will become what they are running from. cammeel1

	merlion, on 05/04/2008 @ 12:54 AM wrote:
		I completely agree with your letter. It is past time that people remember that illegal immigrants are in fact commiting a crime by being here.

	donnadyar, on 05/05/2008 @ 04:12 PM wrote:
		You are exactly correct on this,securing the borders needs to be done.We need to protect are borders better.If they want to come over legal fine,but not illegal.

	Simplyme, on 05/06/2008 @ 02:15 AM wrote:
		There are so many reasons I agree with this letter, but one of the concerns I share is the work issues. Few and far between (here in AZ) can you find a decent paying job because of the extreme numbers of illegal immigrants who are willing to do the work for pennies. I am a citizen and my children do not deserve to starve because all our jobs are taken.

	Bees, on 05/06/2008 @ 12:35 PM wrote:
		Absolutely. We have rules to enter the country. Those of us who were born here are bound to the rules like taxes etc. It is a basic issue- you come in illegally, you have already broken our laws and disrespected our country. Legitimate amnesty aside, I do not think we should be soft on illegals.

	adamwebber, on 05/06/2008 @ 01:40 PM wrote:
		Minute Men! Minute Men!

	racyrefinedraj, on 05/06/2008 @ 09:55 PM wrote:
		So we've got millions upon millions of (generally speaking) hard working folk who want nothing but to enter our country, obey our laws, work a decent job, and pay taxes, and this is a problem?

	pjamerican, on 05/06/2008 @ 11:53 PM wrote:
		You well thought out remarks are exactly right. Politicians need to stop the talk about immigration reform. America has all the laws it needs. Time to enforce them.

	Rocky45, on 05/07/2008 @ 11:49 PM wrote:
		Although I basically agree with writer, I would like to add that we must deal with the immigration issue with both humanity and responsibility. For years, we, the richest nation on earth had a fenceless border that made it easy for millions of hungry, desperate and hard working people to enter our country. So we need to take responsibility for that. Also, there are people who've been here for years and built families here. We should have a statute of limitations and let people who, say, have lived here 10+ years and have children born here 'buy' legal residence for 5, 10 or X thousand dollars.

	krystal0409, on 05/08/2008 @ 06:33 PM wrote:
		Our border security truly is a mess, as is so many other things. When will it be a priority-not until its too late I think.

	oreofudge, on 05/08/2008 @ 07:00 PM wrote:
		Absolutely the central concern is national security. We need to strengthen out northern borders as-well-as our southern borders. What really gets me is this new term being thrown around, undocumented workers. It still means you are illegal! I feel really bad for the people who and have become citizens the right way. I understand that many immigrants are here to make a better life and they just don't know what the laws are here, that's why we need to secure our borders so we can help these people become full, productive citizens the right way.

	xatlasm, on 05/09/2008 @ 09:25 PM wrote:
		Illegal aliens have no right to skip over the wait to enter this country legally just because they have convenient entry into this country.

	lisatucker, on 05/11/2008 @ 06:55 AM wrote:
		illegals come in az and the result is when an american looks for a job they are practically REQUIRed TO SPEAK SPANISH - or should i say mexican.....shame!

	vsmith, on 05/12/2008 @ 02:44 PM wrote:
		Yes, security is at issue here, and so are American jobs. But the arrogance of Americans who refuse to learn a foreign language and/or treat immigrants like dirt infuriates me.

	Shay77, on 05/12/2008 @ 07:58 PM wrote:
		In a day when so many cry discrimination, this topic begs the question.....What about all the immigrants who have obeyed the law? Isn't this really discrimination against those who have worked hard to be here legally? And if we are going to allow the Mexicans to get away with it, where do we draw the line? We can hardly give them the green light and then force all other nations to continue struggling to get here. Will you afford those who come from terrorist saturated nations to have free access too? Ridiculous.

	liberty4all, on 05/13/2008 @ 05:32 AM wrote:
		People talk often about securing borders and keeping people out of the country. Everyone has their own plan to make it work, but it seems as though no plan ever does. At times it seems we are attempting to micromanage our population.

	wizdoom, on 05/13/2008 @ 03:40 PM wrote:
		illegal immigrants. This is rather a issue . But this has to be handled in a better way. Deporting them or punishing them will not address concern.

	mountainmom, on 05/15/2008 @ 10:52 AM wrote:
		Everyone complaining about the US losing jobs if we cut down on immigration, think about how many million people FROM the US are on unemployment because there are no jobs out there?

	Erin285, on 05/17/2008 @ 07:28 PM wrote:
		You've made some interesting point and given me alot to think about regarding this issue. Ultimately don't agree nor disagree, but i see your point. I appreciate you well thought explaination of the issue.

	Ahimoth, on 05/20/2008 @ 05:25 PM wrote:
		It seems a lot of people here are only seeing what they want to see. Yes, almost 100% of us here in the USA come from immigrants at some point in our family history. So yes, Immigrants can be a good thing. The problem at hand here is rampant ILLEGAL immigration. There are countless individuals in this country who did not follow the rules yet are benefitting from our society. They don't pay taxes (for the most part), yet use all the same resources that a naturalized citizen uses. Resources such as roads, schools, and medical care to name a couple big ones. I don't have a problem with someone coming to our county with dreams of making a better life. I just ask that you make the same contribution and commitment that the rest of us do. Like pay the same taxes and abide by the same laws.

	SWIFFJUSTICE, on 05/20/2008 @ 06:02 PM wrote:
		We will not be satisfied until a full fledge coup d'etat is in our mist,and we fighting to keep our own land from being overtaken by our neighbor.

	Edaun24, on 05/20/2008 @ 08:46 PM wrote:
		I completely agree that businesses that hire illegal immigrants need to be targeted. If these businesses suffer major consequences, such as pricey fines and possibly more severe consequences, they will be less likely to hire illegals. Jobs are the main reason why illegals come to live here. If we eliminate the jobs, they won't have reasons to come here illegally.

	empressofanime, on 05/22/2008 @ 08:32 AM wrote:
		Okay, secure the borders. How? I don't want to live in a military state, and can you imagine how much man power would be required to secure the borders? Plus, if just 10% of those men are corrupt...

	amanda, on 05/22/2008 @ 01:11 PM wrote:
		I agree with this. No one should be allowed to live here illegally. The rules should be the same for all.

	pryncessamber78, on 05/23/2008 @ 07:31 AM wrote:
		border security should be much tighter. its no wonder we can control anything. we just close our eyes and allow these things to happen

	Celestial, on 05/24/2008 @ 10:02 AM wrote:
		I think we all want to have secure borders but the real question is does the government really want it? I think either they have not enough manpower to put to this cause, or they really want illegals to come here to work for dirt cheap wages and so they continue to allow it. Oh, sure, they make gestures like they are trying to stop it, but seriously, do they care? They want these people to come up here to work for this millionaires in corporations who can pay them 50 cents an hour and have no legal recourse if they are abused or whatever. It's the rich in control, per usual. I am surprised more people aren't hip to this. We want security, we all do. But this is the material world, nobody is truly secure and safe here. Look to God for real security, for true safety. If you expect the government to save your behind, you'll be sadly disappointed. Bless you!

	JDog, on 05/24/2008 @ 04:11 PM wrote:
		Securing our border is absolutely a necessity. If it were not, we even bother with the border checkpoints at Tijauna and Tecate and the others? It's absolutely insane that this is even up for debate. Secure the borders and create a program to manage any employment needs afterwards. And this argument that Americans won't do these jobs? That's complete bull****. Americans won't do the jobs for $2 / hour, but a illegal immigrant will. This is tantamount to slavery and should be stopped.

	SUFFERERSO, on 05/27/2008 @ 10:48 AM wrote:
		We as a nation want be satisfied until the sanctity of our sanity is compromised by the loose threads which holds or brittle borders intact. Secure the dam borders by whatever means necessary !

	jlaney, on 05/28/2008 @ 01:35 PM wrote:
		Illegal immigration is "illegal"! Where is the debate? Try to illegally enter other countries and you'll find yourself on the first plane, boat, ship, train, or donkey cart out. There are legal ways to enter the US. Use them.

	n_baker, on 05/29/2008 @ 12:31 AM wrote:
		illegals from anywhere are illegal, and are not deserving of any rights within our country. if we went into any other country and did the things they did here, we would be deported instantly.

	moonchyldfyre, on 05/29/2008 @ 06:06 AM wrote:
		Another great topic I agree on. It is crazy how more and more of our jobs, money, housing etc etc etc is all being taken over by illegal immigrants and then they go back to their own countries and live like kinds. It is just plain not right. We end up losing out in the long run.

	pauld43, on 06/05/2008 @ 11:38 PM wrote:
		It is a national security issue.We have no idea who is coming across the border.Criminal,terrorists who knows.We have enough internal problems weithout more sneaking across the border.

	deaglemck, on 06/17/2008 @ 11:12 AM wrote:
		I agree, illegal is illegal no matter how you put it. I understand they have reasons and all but unless they can come legally then how are we supposed to feel if we want to hire someone who is here illegaly? We're in a moral dilemma.

	hatedout, on 06/17/2008 @ 11:30 AM wrote:
		Funny how you praise the Bush administration and conveniently overlook how the last 8 years has been a complete failure when it comes to immigration reform. I guess this will be the next Presidents problem. Nobody but Lou Dobbs will take a chance offending Mexicans.

	rockbirdstar, on 06/17/2008 @ 07:40 PM wrote:
		Illegal immigration is unfair to all those who want to enter legally and even more unfair to those who have already entered through the legal channels - some waiting years for the paperwork.

	ceciliaraespam, on 06/19/2008 @ 11:16 AM wrote:
		As Katya states "Our border security is a mess." I cannot understand how our country expects its own citizens to obey the law, but will not enforce laws aimed at illegal aliens.

	bveach07, on 06/19/2008 @ 12:02 PM wrote:
		Yes illegals are a problem no matter how good they are doing taking jobs, and entering illegally are a problem!

	fatimah, on 06/19/2008 @ 07:55 PM wrote:
		. I think we should allow controlled numbers of migrant workers with a separate set of wage regulations. They are coming here because they make more money than in Mexico, so I don't see how it is a disservice to them to pay them less than Americans. Is it more of a service to force them to stay in Mexico and earn a fraction of that pay?

	imaforevergirl, on 06/20/2008 @ 12:33 PM wrote:
		umm yea i think that you need to get off your high horse there Nepolian and think about how you even came to be in this country...rememeber the only NATIVES to america are the native amerians

	HeyImLA, on 06/21/2008 @ 07:59 AM wrote:
		I absolutely agree! The current rhetoric of allowing amnesty to illegals didn't work when Ronald Reagan tried it during his administration - the problem has only quadrupled since then. (Forgive me, Lord, because I LOVED Reagan as a President!!) We need to start showing both the immigrants and the companies that are hiring them that they will be deported, and the workforce of illegals will dry up! As soon as they learn they stand a better chance of being sent back to their home country, they will begin realizing the risk isn't worth the reward.

	nanfd, on 06/21/2008 @ 09:32 AM wrote:
		Maybe if the immigration system was a more effective machine these "people" would be able to apply and get the visas that many so desparately want to come to this country.

	wildermommiex3, on 06/21/2008 @ 05:17 PM wrote:
		All illegals should be treated by law the same way the American people are when they break laws. Being here against our countries laws is ILLEGAL and they should be reprimanded the same as you would for any other law abiding citizen.

	TinyTee1971, on 06/22/2008 @ 02:10 PM wrote:
		You have excellent points but there is no way this problem is going to get any better. It keeps getting worse and worse, and no one does a thing.

	lucyadaire, on 06/24/2008 @ 12:44 PM wrote:
		I wonder if you've ever faced the troubles of undocumented workers. Well, no, I don't. Clearly you have no comprehension. I DO wonder, though, if you remember middle school history lessons of how people with pale skin ever showed up here - you know, the English, or maybe Columbus' crew - anytime 'White men' stepped foot here before we called it the USA... WE WERE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS. We weren't here first. And you don't see the Native Americans trying to kick us out. It would be futile. And your argument is also futile. When the Mexican population in this country outweighs the Caucasian, like the Caucasian outweighed the Native American... I do wonder if you'll be asking for your land, your rights, and your respect back from the people you wanted to keep out. The only difference is that we're much bigger assholes than the Native Americans ever were. Well, SOME of us, anyway.

	lucyadaire, on 06/24/2008 @ 12:47 PM wrote:
		However, I do agree that businesses taking part in unfair worker condition and treatment should be fined. The people who need to, in your opinion, be deported, however... should be given information on how to do right in this country, or politely asked to leave. If he have a good system for cracking down on mistreatment of migrant workers in bad workplaces, they will be found again. Maybe they get a 2 strikes, and on the 3rd, they're deported. That seems more than fair to me.

	mystermyke1, on 07/06/2008 @ 12:03 AM wrote:
		oh my i just read about this in the other post. draw the line of scrimmage cross the line to early its a penalty! they shouldnt be shunned and deported, if the person has no criminal background and only the crime is wanting to live in a free country is wrong kill me in my twentys in the name of progress

	The_Guru, on 07/10/2008 @ 10:20 AM wrote:
		Well, I agree with you on immigration and disagree on global warming. Guess that just shows you can't be wrong all the time... Seriously, immigration is something that has basically been ignored since this country was founded. You'd think somebody in government would have gotten a clue in 230+ years.

	AnneNonnimus, on 07/16/2008 @ 12:36 PM wrote:
		So many letters have hit the point already. It obviously is more than Mexicans migrating across the border. I think, however unfortunate, the borders will never ever be locked and secure. There will always be a way to get in illegally. But that's not to say I throw my hands up and don't care.

	hekare, on 07/19/2008 @ 02:41 PM wrote:
		In addition to enforcing the laws we already have, it would vastly improve our public schools if they weren't required to constantly dumb down curriculum for the sake of those who (often) refuse to learn English. Stop providing free mandatory daycare!