Residential Wood Smoke On The Rise - Worse Than Tobacco Smoke

Related Issues:  Environmental Policy , Human Rights , Law Enforcement , Global Warming , Green Initiatives

Tags:  wood smoke , outdoor wood boilers , air pollution , smoke , wood stoves , tobacco smoke , carbon emissions

Saturday, 05/02/2009 @ 09:14 PM
To whom it may concern:

 

The growing popularity of outdoor wood-fired boilers (OWB), also known as outdoor wood-fired hydronic heaters or outdoor wood-fired furnaces, has been increasing at an alarming rate, affecting areas of NY, CT, MN, WA, and other states. Although residents voice concerns over health dangers attributed to excessive amounts of toxic smoke emitted by OWBs, there is not enough being done by local and state officials to regulate residential wood smoke.  

Frustrated residents complain, “Our kids are getting sick. Officials are just not listening to our cries for help.” In one Mid Hudson home, two garaged ferrets died after a six month exposure to the smoke of a next door neighbor’s outdoor wood furnace. The homeowners described the smoke as noxious and relentless, stating that it set off their smoke alarm almost daily. “We finally had to disconnect it [our smoke alarm]. That’s a fire hazard as far as we’re concerned.” Another complained she had to keep scrubbing soot off her bedroom walls. Needless to say, when it comes to the issue of, to burn or not to burn, arguments between neighbors and local officials have been cropping up in many municipalities throughout New York and other states. “Canada is a step ahead of us in bans and regulation of wood smoke,” states Victoria Valentine who is involved with USA and Canadian groups fighting for wood smoke regulation. “We’re fighting for our freedom to breathe clean air and right to quiet enjoyment of our homes and healthy lifestyle.”

Clean Air Hudson, a group of concerned Mid Hudson Valley residents, has been campaigning for clean air by lobbying local and state officials and agencies, requesting stricter regulation of wood smoke that is now flowing freely in our air, polluting and promoting illness. “Along with our request for regulation, we are asking New York to follow the lead of Connecticut’s recent attempt to protect residents from wood smoke,” states Valentine, founder of www.cleanairhudson.com. HB 6616, AN ACT ESTABLISHING WOOD SMOKE TO BE A PUBLIC NUISANCE, if passed, wouldredefine wood smoke as a public health nuisance and allow action to be taken to protect people in their own homes, Margaret R. LaCroix of the American Lung Association of New England reports.

“We don’t want to deprive anyone of the right to burn wood but believe oversight is necessary to protect health and environment. Burning wood should never be the primary source of heat and hot water for any home. Limitations would help alleviate some of the high concentrations of wood smoke affecting many areas where residents are gravely affected.” Valentine insists, “Wood smoke is more than an annoyance; it can become a severe health hazard when fine particulate matter is inhaled and lodges in your lungs. We want the public to know.”

Valentine herself was treated last fall for serious respiratory damage resulting from wood smoke inhalation when her next door neighbor tried to heat his home solely with wood. Involuntarily breathing the excessive smoke caused what her doctor called internal sunburn complicated by a staph infection.

Burning wood for heat and hot water is not GREEN as the wood stove industry and other proponents proclaim. It blankets the atmosphere with black carbon soot that contributes to global warming. Wood smoke contains carcinogenic particulates along with some of the greenhouse gases the Obama Administration is pushing to control: carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons and sulfur hexafluoride that negatively impact our planet.

When you live in close proximity to a wood burning device you may be exposed to 24/7 smoke inhalation, which is as bad as or worse than breathing second hand tobacco smoke. Exposure to wood smoke causes an array of symptoms such as headaches, burning eyes, nose, throat and chest. The American Lung Association and the EPA agree that wood smoke exposure worsens or can cause asthma and respiratory illness along with a host of other illnesses. Scientific studies find pregnant women, children and the elderly to be most at risk. Wood smoke has been linked to SIDS [Sudden Infant Death Syndrome] and may weaken healthy immune systems leading to premature death, and the list goes on.

“Inhalation of wood smoke should be avoided,” states the EPA website which recently provided information on wood stove swap-outs. This concerns Valentine. “On one hand they warn of the dangers of wood smoke and on the other they offer tax credits for those who want to swap an old wood stove for a new one. Smoke is smoke. Why not swap wood stoves for clean burning gas or electric stoves?”

Wood smoke crosses property lines, hovers and surrounds homes, infiltrating through closed doors and windows, walls, electrical outlets and normal air exchange. Even if you don’t see or smell the smoke, if you live next door to or near an operating OWB or wood stove, toxic smoke is more than likely entering your home, affecting the health of your family. “We have tobacco smoke restrictions,” Valentine argues, “why not wood smoke? You can avoid cigarette smoke, but you can’t avoid breathing contaminated air in your own home that’s being bombarded by your neighbor’s wood smoke. Would you give your kids a carton of cigarettes and tell them to chain-smoke? Exposing them to wood smoke on a daily basis is just as bad, if not worse.”

Sources: burningissues.org, nescaum.org, epa.gov, lungusa.org, woodsmokefreeny.com

VictoriaSky

http://www.cleanairhudson.com

http://www.woodsmokefreeny.com

Very Disgusted
VictoriaSky
View All    |   Sort by Newest First
Letter Comments
Total Comments: 19
againstwoodburning,  on 05/03/2009 @ 09:12 AM  wrote:
Wood smoke trespasses, is a nuisance, is a health menace and creates particulate pollution. Particulates are the 2nd leading cause of global warming, and reducing or eliminating them is the quickest way to slow climate change. Wood burning is done by people who can afford to use other methods of heating, but if they need financial help, the government is able to help them, if they demonstrate their penury. The people who are victimized by wood smoke from their neighbors are more often poor people, who develop lung and heart problems.
efreaq,  on 05/04/2009 @ 10:19 AM  wrote:
I agree with you about OWBs. I feel that something should be done to minimize the environmental impact of these and other such devices. Don't forget all the wood burning fire paces that are still in use inside the home. If we can make burning coal less harmful in large scale operations, then it should be easy to make filter systems for home burning systems at a price that people are willing to pay.
phydo,  on 05/05/2009 @ 04:08 AM  wrote:
I don't know enough yet about the subject to be objective. (I will though). One of my most treasured memories is the smell of the small towns in the mountains I used to be able to visit in the winter. The snow covered hills, the rosy cheeked hellos and smiles, the welcome entry into a friends or family members home warmed by God's gift of fire. I long for the simplicity of life that those days remind me of. I live in Florida on rural property and one of my neighbors enjoys burning his yard waste in a barrel. I love the smell of it. It stirs a primal and pleasant memory.
xchrishall,  on 05/06/2009 @ 02:36 PM  wrote:
Something really needs to be done aboutall of the pollution and smog being filtered into our air, hopefully something is done soon.
spiderwomann,  on 05/06/2009 @ 04:04 PM  wrote:
I have asthma and have a terrible time being able to breathe, and my problem is certainly exacerbated by wood smoke.
azpitcher,  on 05/06/2009 @ 09:08 PM  wrote:
There is a lot of truth to the problem described. Many Counties around the country have no burn nights when the cloud cover is low. Unless you have a environmentally safe woodburning stove or fireplace you cannot burn on these nights or you risk a fine. I know that there is the arguement that we are stepping on peoples rights but how about the people who have to ebdure the health effects of the burning during unhealthy conditions.
mohitpareek,  on 05/07/2009 @ 07:16 AM  wrote:
wood smoke is polluting the air in big way it need to curtailed in a serious manner.
dymesllc,  on 05/07/2009 @ 12:03 PM  wrote:
This is a pretty big problem were I live. Once you start smelling the smoke, it's like you can't escape it.
Everlong,  on 05/07/2009 @ 02:34 PM  wrote:
Wood smoke is also an issue where I live. Not only does it release pollutants into the air but also causes animals and children to become sick. I agree with you letter VictoriaSky. We need regulations and restrictions on the wood burners. I don't want my future children getting sick from an issue that could be easily fixed by regulation.
TylerJ,  on 05/10/2009 @ 11:31 AM  wrote:
I lived in an area with large amounts of controlled burns for a few years, when ever it was that time i would have Asama so bad i could hardly function.
fergusbb,  on 05/10/2009 @ 09:31 PM  wrote:
I'm another person who does is not well versed in the particular situation but is a scientist and knows for sure that burning wood for energy is not the "Green" choice.
cbushong28,  on 05/11/2009 @ 08:40 PM  wrote:
I'm not sure but, isn't this illegal in some sates?
VictoriaSky,  on 05/12/2009 @ 10:18 AM  wrote:
It may be illegal in a few states but very limited regulations are in force. Most municipalities let you choke to death before they even listen to you - and then they still don't do anything. I have some shocking videos I'm going to upload to my site shortly. Look at how these poor people are living. We have a constant fight on our hands just because we want to breathe clean air. They give the burners more rights. But it's more than that - it's politics, greed, wood stove industry, a smelly cocktail of smoke and injustice. http://www.woodsmokefreeny.com
LilyJDragonfly,  on 05/14/2009 @ 08:12 PM  wrote:
I suppose that when a wildfire breaks out near your home (as it does often here in CA), you will stuff all doors with wet towels and cancel outdoor activities until the fires are over. Truly, this is why America is over-regulated. "oooh. This is dangerous! Let's pass a law!"
VictoriaSky,  on 05/14/2009 @ 09:19 PM  wrote:
With people like you around, yes we need to pass laws. Your post response is ridiculous. Keep breathing your CA forest fires. It's numbing your senses to the point that you don't even realize how silly you sound.
beinghappy4ever,  on 05/31/2009 @ 04:42 PM  wrote:
This is really becoming something harming our living environment. But than opposing this, it will be fine to get proper ways to effectively do this..
StopWoodBurning,  on 06/04/2009 @ 08:59 AM  wrote:
With all due respect xchrishall, Hoping someone will do something soon never works. Never has and never will. Write your local, state, federal (and yes Obama, Jackson and Browner too) politicians and the State and Federal EPAtelling them you want air for you, your children and grandchildren to breathe instead of soot and dangerous chemicals from you neighbors indoor and outdoor wood burning. Nothing positive has ever occurred by sitting around hoping and waiting for others to do it for you.
meofcourse80,  on 07/03/2009 @ 07:55 PM  wrote:
I don't really know enough on this issue to form a definite opinion and this letter is totally one-sided, but I could see that maybe this is something that would need to be regulated in an urban or suburban setting. But I think it would only make sense to regulate at a city level, not state or national.
VictoriaSky,  on 07/06/2009 @ 08:12 AM  wrote:
Hi - If you lived with this sickening smoke, you would understand this letter and what we are trying to convey. Visit http://www.burningissues.org for information re: harm and effects of residential woodsmoke on humans, animals & environment. At this time, our county and state are working on regulations, because the situation has become "that bad". Visit my site: http://www.woodsmokefreeny.com for videos. I think you will then understand this is more than nuisance-it's severe health issues.