Invite Your Friends to Join!   |   Write A Letter Now!   |   Home   |   Feedback   |   Report Abuse   |   Login
Speak Out! Be Heard!
Authored By: Mollotchka
Interact with Citizen

Educating Immigrants

Related Issues:  Education , Immigration Policy , Law Enforcement

Tags:  education , immigrants , english

Similar Letters: Search for letters similar to this one

Sunday, 06/01/2008 @ 05:18 PM
To whom it may concern:
Immigrants who come to our nation need to have opportunities to learn English and learn about the laws of the land so that they can assimilate into our culture. Of course, every family chooses to practice religion in their own way, eat their own choices of foods, listen to their choices of music, etc. But there needs to be a stronger support network that welcomes legal immigrants to our communites. When they aren't welcomed and aren't provided opportunities to learn English and learn our laws, why are we so surprised that they don't assimilate to American culture? There needs to be more funding for adult education and immigrant support services.
Warm Regards,
Mollotchka
View All    |   Sort by Newest First
Letter Comments
Total Comments: 224
 BennyBoy,  on 06/01/2008 @ 11:11 PM  wrote:
From what I understand, and i could be wrong on this, when you are going through the process of becoming a legal citizen you do take classes in english as well as classes on American culture/history. If you are referring to illegal immagrants, then I do agree with you that they need to learn about the laws of the land and they need to go home and apply to come to America legally.
Mollotchka,  on 06/02/2008 @ 02:57 PM  wrote:
Legal immigrants must find their own help. It is not provided for them by the USCIS as part of the citizenship process. In most cases, legal immigrants must be residents for 3-5 years before starting the citizenship process. In the meantime there must be more opportunities for immigrants to learn and to become a part of American society instead of segregating or becoming isolated. I think this should come from you and me. Americans need to reach out a welcoming hand, rather than to look at all immigrants with suspicion and bigotry.
JDog,  on 06/02/2008 @ 02:58 PM  wrote:
Immigrants who come to this country legally do, in fact, need to learn basic english and pass a basic US history test. The immigrants going through the legal channels, though, are not the ones that bother me. It's the ones that come here illegally that are the problem.
phmcd,  on 06/05/2008 @ 05:53 AM  wrote:
I agree. Not every country gives its people the opportunity to learn. We need a quality, educated workforce.
cotton0821,  on 06/05/2008 @ 05:55 AM  wrote:
It is simplistic to lump all immigrants together. There are ones who wish to become Americans and they make the effort on their own. Then there are immigrants who do not wish to become Americans since they view the US as merely a cash cow which they will leave when they are done. These people do not need taxpayer funded assimilation since they really do not want it.
CrystalD,  on 06/07/2008 @ 01:30 PM  wrote:
I don't understand what other opportunities you would like to see since every person has the opportunity to join the school system (K-12) and there are a myriad of adult education programs in this country already. If the opportunities are there then I think it is up to each of us (immigrant or not) to pursue them if we would like. CrystalD
cbburke1116,  on 06/09/2008 @ 09:58 AM  wrote:
The United States is the land of opportunity. Most legal immigrants I know have taken full advantage of the opportunites given to them. The United States provides the best services in the world for legal immigrants to assimilate. When someone starts talking about more funding, that just means higher taxes. So I would think twice about making a comment like that.
SAdams,  on 06/09/2008 @ 12:33 PM  wrote:
I agree with you here. In order for immigrants to be able to interact successfully with our culture is to be given the chance to learn about it.
towalkindignity,  on 06/09/2008 @ 03:31 PM  wrote:
This is so true. Most immigrants have taken a brave step by coming here at all, generally to be met with derision. If Americans want to complain about all of the immigrants who don't learn English, we could at least make sure we're doing our part to help them do so.
OrdinaryName,  on 06/10/2008 @ 02:14 AM  wrote:
I don't understand where this letter is coming from. Having been born in American, I don't have the perspective of being a stranger in a strange land, but I know that there are opportunities there if one would just take advantage of them. So perhaps it is a regional problem or a funding problem.
MadScience,  on 06/11/2008 @ 12:13 PM  wrote:
As a legal immigrant myself, I totally agree with you. I was fortunate to have come to a community of very friendly people who welcomed me and helped me, but it would be great to have some official infrastructure in place to make sure this is available to all legal immigrants.
AnnaBov,  on 06/11/2008 @ 02:58 PM  wrote:
I agree with you in the sense that we absolutely need to make adult learning facilities more readily available. I do however feel that this letter could be improved be relating a personal story or reason for your concern.
candyapple,  on 06/12/2008 @ 05:45 PM  wrote:
If the services aren't already available (which I think they might be) the I agree 100%. It's not just a, this is America and we speak English here, thing but it will make life easier for the people who wish to settle here with finding employment and assimilating into society.
gravitonring,  on 06/13/2008 @ 08:46 AM  wrote:
Thanks for your kind letter Mollotchka. I hope we can continue to help every human to develop skills and understanding of how to communicate and support each other. I really believe that humans need to see the earth as a common home for all of us, since we are all cousins in our DNA :) The problem of human behavior must be solved. We still do not know how to prevent our own violence against our own human family.
amillwar,  on 06/13/2008 @ 10:33 AM  wrote:
I agree. They need to learn English and our culture or we'll be going around in circles. Let's face it, we can't send 'em all back. Let's prevent future situations where we can't handle the immigration and educate those who are here.
SmilnAtYa2,  on 06/13/2008 @ 02:26 PM  wrote:
People always just assume that they are being helped. We need to educate those around us and take a stand for those in need.
hoppingviola,  on 06/13/2008 @ 04:01 PM  wrote:
I think your argument here is a little too simplified. I also have to disagree with the idea that "assimilation" is the best thing for anyone, especially immigrants.
msbyte,  on 06/13/2008 @ 07:12 PM  wrote:
My mother came to this country LEGALLY in the late 1950's. She went to school, learned English, got married, had children, and lived her life. She went back to Germany in the 80's to take care of her ailing father. When she returned I had to sponsor her return, promise that I would pay for all of her needs and sign papers that she would not rely on government support. In the process we were treated like sub-citizens. We dared not say anything about our treatment for fear of reprisal. It was a humiliating experience and sickening considering I am a citizen of this country (so is my father, his family came over in 1890's). Public Servants need to realize that their job is to serve, not to be jerks. The money given this area could be much better spent, but to many people want to spew hatred and ignorance.
ting912,  on 06/14/2008 @ 08:27 AM  wrote:
Throwing money at an issue doesn't SOLVE anything. I myself am a non-citizen going thru USCIS. I have completed 6-12 grade here in the United States. Arriving with no knowledge of what being an American is about to becoming a spearheaded patriot of my graduating class; I believe that one needs the Drive and Passion to assimilate in order to become a full flange American. America already has an abundance of avenues where Non-Citizens can find education and knowledge; many simply just lack the Drive and Passion. Simply stating that “There needs to be more funding for adult education and immigrant support services,” Will not solve anything.
julieleaps,  on 06/14/2008 @ 08:15 PM  wrote:
Those choices you mentioned come with the privilege of being here legally. And so is the choice to assimilate or not.
leto17,  on 06/15/2008 @ 07:59 AM  wrote:
More should be done, but there is some good news. One comforting thing is that historically, children of immigrants become acclimatited and "Amerricanized" relatively quickly. Key to this process is their interaction with and entrance into parts of American society not affliated with their original ethnic background. In other words, they go out and play with firends at shcool, get girlfriends of different ethnicity, and learn to speak English in school. They can then help their parents enter into society more.
Claire,  on 06/15/2008 @ 02:12 PM  wrote:
I think you make a very good point about our own failure to help immigrants integrate into American society. In many cases, integration is not a simple choice, it's a matter of opportunity and support.
moonwalker,  on 06/16/2008 @ 04:34 AM  wrote:
I agree that more funding should be put into adult education and immigrant support services. This would be good for citizens and would improve the daily lives of those becoming citizens.
delzakiya,  on 06/16/2008 @ 11:45 AM  wrote:
You know what, there are TONS of places for legal immigrants to learn English, but I think you mean free. I will let that pass. There are Adult Education programs, ESL, online opportunities galour. I think if you want to find it you will. The language is just one aspect. The other is the culture. That varies by state and city, so there can be no big "inclusion" thing.
rhinog,  on 06/16/2008 @ 12:05 PM  wrote:
I think immigrants do need to learn how to communicate and educate themselves to make life easier for them and ourselves. I also think this should be something they seek and not something we provide specifically for them. We have to find ways to provide these services to our citizens first and then others that come into the country.
m_kim5553,  on 06/16/2008 @ 03:16 PM  wrote:
I totally agree with you. If I went to France, I would have to learn French - as it is their official language. The problem is that America doesn't have an official language. Obviously we have an unofficial language, but it's hard to force a language down the throat of immigrants when we really don't have an official language.
jakimyny1,  on 06/17/2008 @ 12:58 AM  wrote:
I don't think she's referring only to legal immigrants. Those that are legal or becoming legal are probably fairly well educated individuals but there a masses upon masses of illegal aliens that we come into contact with each day and become irritated by because their accent is too thick or just don't seem American enough and too foreing. The fact of the matter is that if we didn't turn our back to them by creating laws that don't change the fact of them being here we shouldn't complain. We don't do much of anything to address immigrants of any kind practically. They have to simply manage on their own or hope that those that came before them will show them the way.
Shyteal,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:06 AM  wrote:
There are many programs that can help immigrants if they chose to use them. unfortunately many of them don't instead they want us to change our ways. America started with many different cultures working together with reasonable acceptance of how to worship and live but to come together as a whole. If we were in their country we would be expected to partake in their culture, I feel they should embrace or ignore our not not try to change it by saying that they need more education.
CYCLOPS,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:41 AM  wrote:
I agree that there needs to be a stronger support network here. However, I believe that there is a way we can support these immigrants without them having to assimilate.
lovelymrw,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:48 AM  wrote:
I agree that we should teach all immigrants english, there is no way they'll become successful in this society if they can't function in it. However, due to our current economy, I believe it's more immportant to put money into helping our citizens survive these hard times.
xoxobethanyxox,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:00 AM  wrote:
I understand the controversy about illegal immigrants, but our country is known for our freedoms. We should be proud that people from around the world want to live here. So, yes, they should be helped to have a better life here and to assimilate.
lollypopshoppe1,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:07 AM  wrote:
we need to educate AMERICANS and close the doors to the flood of immigrants coming into our country. their own country needs to foot the bill for educating their people.
skelly7483,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:15 AM  wrote:
This is the thinking that I dont like "more funding", so we can have those mexicans who dont pay taxes come over hear and get more free stuff.
JenEGolden,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:20 AM  wrote:
Whether you are speaking of illegal or legal immigrants, education is an integral part of cultural assimilation. Benjamin Franklin, a strong proponent of public education, recognized that immigrants who were not given the opportunity to attend school would only perpetuate the cycle of ignorance and isolation.
Twnkls1,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:29 AM  wrote:
I think if there were more possibilities for ANY immigrant to assimilate, through classes or other things that we wouldn't be turning into a nation that has no seemingly unidentifiable language or identity.
kmc0107,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:32 AM  wrote:
There are ample opportunities for immigrants to learn the English language and learn about the laws of this country. They just have to seek out the help. One of the best ways to do that is to apply for legal citizenship.
Shiloh33,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:33 AM  wrote:
I think if we do not educate these people it will make things like crime and healthcare even worse. I disagree and feel we need to educate them to give the rest of the taxpaying public a chance to make things better.
Jeskel83,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:43 AM  wrote:
MORE funding they get all the government funding now as it is. If your a low income white american you can't get anything. Why because immigrants get it. They work under the table making more money than I do they don't pay taxes and they get all the tax money. I think what you are saying is ridiculous they have the means to learn they choose not to, they make there money and then ship it off back to there country and that money goes into there economy probally why we are all struggling here because that money went somewhere else and boosted other countries so the demand for needed resourses are higher.
LoveKnits,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:51 AM  wrote:
As BennyBoy mentioned, to become a LEGAL American Citizen, you are required to speak English, as well as learn the culture/history of the US. There is a huge support system for legal immigrants. The main non-assimilation problem comes from illegal immigrants, who come here, refuse to leave, then cry when we won't give them free stuff anymore.
popedragon,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:51 AM  wrote:
I completely agree with this letter. I can't stand the fact of seeing spanish people taking our jobs and not taking the time to learn our language and our culture. I know that when I go to another counrty I at least try to learn a little of their language and culture before Ithrow myself into it.
leereba437,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:00 AM  wrote:
I think that even the Legal immigrants need to be in charge of finding their own resources to integrate themselves into our society, after all it is their choice to come to the united states; no one is forcing them here, therefore let it be up to them to accimulate themselves to our standards.
87cate,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:06 AM  wrote:
I recently had a friend go through this process. The government offers study materials, but finding other resources is up to the immigrants. I agree that Americans need to be more welcoming and understanding. We live in a wonderful country and should want to share our knowledge and love for our homeland.
Cbra131,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:12 AM  wrote:
If they are going to use the system anyway, why don't we make it efficient and effective? That makes sense.
Affliction22,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:18 AM  wrote:
I agree that there need to be more opportunities for legal immigrants to learn english, however, I don't think it shoul dbe at the expense of our tax payers.
kmtchllx2,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:25 AM  wrote:
I do not oppose learning centers for immigrants but, I think they are not the only people that need help. Just look at how many of are own citizens need help with learning. If they had a decent education, they would have better jobs. Education is the key to ending poverty, but some people do not want to be helped.
skreemastr,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:25 AM  wrote:
I agree that everyone should learn english,but we should all learn a second language(like most other countries) so we are not the dumbest nation in the future
Ineedmoney50,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:26 AM  wrote:
We dont need to teach Illegal immigrants ok! But If they are going to live here all the need to learn is English then they need to learn how to work that lawnmower. And thats all I have to say -Buddah Blue
dman45456,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:39 AM  wrote:
I believe that all (legal) Americans should have the right to a proper education and immigrants should not have to sacrifrice their education just becuase of their hertiage.
Honey1r,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:40 AM  wrote:
I beleive when you want to be a part of something you feel so strongly about that you would risk your life to get to it, you should take the initative to learn all you need to about that something so you can benefit from it.
ccarney,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:51 AM  wrote:
If immigrants are going to be legally allowed to become citizens then I also believe that more innitiatives need to be put in place in order to teach them more about the country they live in. I'm pretty sure americans would not like to be thrown into a country and recieve no knowledge on how to adapt and live there.
mmmpeachy,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:54 AM  wrote:
I think the impetus has to be on the immigrant to want to assimilate into our country and culture. Citizenship classes are paid for with our taxes for those wishing to become citizens. Charities and non-profit groups provide theses services, as well, to anyone wishing to partake. I, myself, would not expect to be given any more than these opportunities if I was to immigrate to any other country!
Fi03_31,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:27 AM  wrote:
We have too many people here already. In the past people assimilated out of desire and need. Today neither of those things exist. We need to stop encouraging immigration, legal and illegal!
ashez143,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:45 AM  wrote:
I think it is highly important for immigrants to learn our native language. It is okay for them to speak as they wish at home, but in the given public, speaking to others, they should speak English.
wrreid,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:45 AM  wrote:
You're right. America is being flooded with different languages right now, and the only thing to do is to educate those newcomers in an American fashion. Stopping immigration entirely is a slippery slope.
EHandel,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:50 AM  wrote:
I beleive that if you live in a country you should at least have to learn the native language
ShanaC,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:52 AM  wrote:
It is a shame that people that come to our country looking to better themselves aren't given the proper tools to do so. I don't see how we, as Americans, can complain about immigrants not "conforming" if all we give them is a little "english 101" and send them on their way.
lind2020,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:53 AM  wrote:
Of course we need to provide basic services to our nations poor, but are these our nations poor or anothers? we clearly arent receiving funding from their home countries.
bcamber19,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:54 AM  wrote:
I believe that immagration is a valuable asset to this coutry but I also believe that immagrants who make the choice to enter into our country should be responsible enough to educate themselves.
sirBAMF,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:56 AM  wrote:
everyone should have an education. When immigrants become educated, thet can help contribute to society.
kvandyke8062,  on 06/17/2008 @ 10:57 AM  wrote:
Unfortunately I do not see this happening any time soon. It is nice to finally read a positive remark in regards to immigrants. People rage about foreigners coming to the US and not speaking the language. Let me ask them this...do they speak the language of every country they have ever been to? Probably not, we believe that we reign supreme. We don't anymore, folks.
acadinfo,  on 06/17/2008 @ 11:05 AM  wrote:
No one should need to learn a language. On the other hand, people should also acknowledge that not learning English will severely limit economic opportunities.
crnstn26,  on 06/17/2008 @ 11:12 AM  wrote:
Even though I do believe in imigration I think that a lot of the problem comes from themselves. They are the ones who move into certain area's and choose to live by there ways. They need to take some initiative of there own and learn our culture.
shannon,  on 06/17/2008 @ 11:53 AM  wrote:
One of the most ignorant things uttered in America is "Speak English or go home." English is one of the most complex and irregular languages in existence. It cannot be mastered simply by observation. One must be taught English, and without a sponsored program for incoming immigrants to learn English, their chances of picking up our language is minimal.
Matthewbonis,  on 06/17/2008 @ 11:59 AM  wrote:
I think that everyone who wants to be a citizen should learn English. I'm not saying that their language is not an important part of who they are, but society shouldn't have to cater to their languages because they don't want to assimilate into OUR culture.
fieari,  on 06/17/2008 @ 12:11 PM  wrote:
Differences between people are important, but similarities matter as well. America must have a culture of it's own... some uniquely identifying feature or average group of features that define us, or we will split apart at the seams, fragmenting into internally warring groups. I support immigration, but more importantly, I support assimilation. On the other hand, I'm not sure the answer is to spend more money to help immigrants assimilate. I'd rather keep those unwilling to try out, and simply accept those willing to try wholeheartedly.
jennycgreen,  on 06/17/2008 @ 12:13 PM  wrote:
Legal immigrants should be treated with the same respect and have the same oppurtunities as US citizens, since they are in fact no different. I didn;t, however, realize that they weren;t being given the nessesary educational oppurtunities.
publishworm,  on 06/17/2008 @ 01:12 PM  wrote:
There are free English classes, drivers ed, art and culture, culinary and a dozen other types of classes available for FREE! Have them check out local resources at city govt level. colleges, hi school and churches. My Polish and Irish ancestors got no tax funding to find what was free!
tashamtholly,  on 06/17/2008 @ 01:34 PM  wrote:
Yes if an immigrant wants to be an American he or she should know about the American history and how to speak the language.
gloriahusk,  on 06/17/2008 @ 01:48 PM  wrote:
Excellent posting. I agree with your point 110%. If we help educate all those who desire an education we only help make the world a better place. Bravo!
Anonythomas,  on 06/17/2008 @ 01:58 PM  wrote:
The availability of knowledge should not be a privilege; it should be a privilege to comprehend that knowledge and know how to use it.
PandaAce,  on 06/17/2008 @ 02:03 PM  wrote:
I agree to a point, i think as a citizen of the "great melting pot" it is our duty like the statue of liberty states to welcome legal immigrants into our land. I believe, however, there is a lot of adult education course and programs to learn english, to help pass the citizen test and the likewise, and ones that aren't free often work on a sliding scale where they review your income and bills and charge you according, if the will is there, the way is there!
024ket,  on 06/17/2008 @ 02:07 PM  wrote:
These programs and funding should come from the country of origin not out of our pocket. You want to come to this country learn the things you need to know before you get here.
dezzy42069,  on 06/17/2008 @ 02:14 PM  wrote:
I don't think we should offer them anything but a kick to the ass out of our country.
easinpc,  on 06/17/2008 @ 02:38 PM  wrote:
I disagree with you in this. If an immigrant comes to the US as a legal citizen they go through classes to learn about the American culture and the English language. They are tested to become a citizen. If they are an illegal immigrant than they shouldn't be offered that help because they didn't care enough to begin with to try and become a legal immigrant.
WeAreAllOne,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:21 PM  wrote:
I completely agree with you. We are the nation of the melting pot and we can't just forget that. These people need to get a chance to a persuit of happiness in this country.
Sweet314548,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:21 PM  wrote:
Why should our hard earned tax dollars go toward educating immigrants?!?!?!? I'm sorry but if they want to come to our country and live in the land of the free then they should be willing to financially support themselves instead of depending on the current residents here to do it for them!!!
cmlewis2290,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:26 PM  wrote:
It's upsetting that we can't do more for immigrants, but as a nation, we have to fix our internal problems amongst citizens before we can focus on branching out.
jorgemacd,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:29 PM  wrote:
Learning English is important, but there are services available. Unfortunately, the people who need them the most don't have the time to use them.
willowweap,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:42 PM  wrote:
I agree that there needs to be more support and funding for adult education and immigrant support services. But I think the adult education should be offered to all, not just immigrants. There are adults in this country that need the same type of help. willowweap
Sanonymous,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:52 PM  wrote:
IYou are absolutely right, there is a need to budget for adult programs especially for immigrants. Sometimes immigrants do not have access to programs that would enhance or benefit educationally. Sanonymous
kellyb,  on 06/17/2008 @ 06:53 PM  wrote:
I agree! I believe this is a major problem and our founding fathers would be proud.
scarygreengiant,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:01 PM  wrote:
Finally, it's nice to see someone with a more balanced viewpoint on immigration. Some people expect these immigrants to learn English overnight. Perhaps they've forgotten about their ancestors.
luckycharr,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:04 PM  wrote:
There are many free classes and opportunities for legal immigrants to learn not only about the American culture, but to learn english. All you need to do is open a community paper and there is always something in there. If you are still not finding anything, most if not ALL community colleges offer some form of class to the non-american immigrant. LuckyCharr
lwilkinson315,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:05 PM  wrote:
Spanish speaking immigrants are a not a problem for me because i can figure out some spanish words but when I come across asians immigrants who cant speak english-- oh boy thats a head ache
gigg423,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:25 PM  wrote:
I agree that legal immigrants should be encouraged to assimilate into the local culture. However I do not think tax dollars should support this. Ideally only people who already know english should be allowed to legally bacome citizens.
MeeshV08,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:31 PM  wrote:
I completely agree with what you are saying in this letter. I think that it's extremely hard for an immigrant to come here, know absolutely nothing about the culture, law, and language, and have to adjust quickly to knowing what is going on. How can we really criticize them for not becoming "one of us" immediately upon stepping foot in the country if there are no real support systems in place?
PAHusker,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:31 PM  wrote:
Although I think immigrants need to learn our language and laws, why should we pay for it with our tax dollars. They decided to come to the US to earn more money so use some of the money to learn our ways.
jojo,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:32 PM  wrote:
Our immigration laws need to be tightened. The last thing we need is to be funding more entitlement programs, especially to those who are not even citizens. We cannot currently affor to educate those who are legally born here. This is certainly not a solution.
xmiss905,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:34 PM  wrote:
I think that you have a very good point. you don't look at them like they are leapers and you are one of the few. They all come to this country for something better and many don't know how to get them. They don't know their options or have support and so they live their lives the best way they know. I think if there were more community programs (private funded perhaps) then maybe they could settle in a lot faster.
DALADYFATIMA,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:41 PM  wrote:
I agree that legal immigrants should be encouraged to assimilate into the local culture. However I do not think tax dollars should support this. Ideally only people who already know english should be allowed to legally bacome citizens.
crystalcierlak,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:58 PM  wrote:
I agree and I think you make an excellent point. But funding this ourselves? There are many community colleges across the country that offer ESL (English as a Second Language) classes that can be obtained for practically free. I think we should put our money to more important places first!
icarus086,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:23 PM  wrote:
I agree. We need to get behind them, but they need to make time. Programs exist, and I'm part of one, but if we don't make them learn, they won't show up. Kind of sad...
politiker,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:23 PM  wrote:
Many programs are already in place for immigrants. I certainly have seen these programs at work. However, immigrants come to our country at a disadvantage and remain that way by not assimilating. They must learn the language and the culture in order to take advantage of the American dream.
PoeticBliss,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:24 PM  wrote:
I agree with this. I have to say though that there is two sides to every story. Although Americans may not be very welcoming at times, immigrants aren't always willing to learn new things either. So we do need to find a happy in between where we can get on one accord and hopefully both cultures will benefit.
KandSMom,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:27 PM  wrote:
There are lots of opportunities for hardworking individual to learn. There are also a shocking number of young people who waste the free education they are provided with by taxpayers. What the education system needs is accountability from parents and students - adults (immigrant and native) need to avail themselves of the services already in place.
itsme32221,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:29 PM  wrote:
I'd like to see immigrants speak English, only I don't think that we taxpayers need to pay for them to learn it. Besides, aren't they taught basic english when they get off the ship? Though, if they have to know very basic American History, why not English?
icarus086,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:33 PM  wrote:
I agree. We need to get behind them, but they need to make time. Programs exist, and I'm part of one, but if we don't make them learn, they won't show up. Kind of sad... icarus086
nemom,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:46 PM  wrote:
I think that immigrants coming to the US come hoping to live the American Dream. I agree that it would be nice to have programs set to help integrate them into the American lifestyle, however that takes more money out of tax payers pockets. I don't feel that it is a wise use of tax dollars.
JamesC06,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:07 PM  wrote:
ok first i want to say i agree that legals should definitely receive more than illegals or else no one will want to go through the process anymore... however i believe legals should have a big sense of responsibility like anyone else, and yes some of our culture should be pushed onto them, if they want to keep their cultures then they need to stay where they are at.
crashedherparty,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:12 PM  wrote:
I agree with what a lot of the other commenters said. Everyone is given an equal opportunity to get basic education. But we can't even afford to give health care to the people born and raised in the US, do you really think that we can/should afford to provide learning centers for adult immigrants? Also, American culture is kind of different depending on where you go in the US, so there can't really be a general "American culture" class, in my opinion.
Krisper311,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:41 PM  wrote:
To become a United States citizen you do have to go through a process, however there are people who are allowed to be here in the United States without having to be a citizen by carrying a green card. One of those people happen to be a family member of mine. It isn't necessarily that they don't have the education, because I have met several people, including my family member, who simply do not want to learn English. She speaks broken English, and could probably be better at it if only she would watch TV in English or speak to her other bilingual friends in English. Unfortunately, she chooses to watch Spanish TV and mostly speaks Spanish with others. Many of these people are offered ESL courses at Community Colleges and can even receive Federal funding to pay for them.
aikifox85,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:44 PM  wrote:
I completely agree with you. It would also help people if we stopped automatically assuming that every immigrant is illegal.
vrtuoswmn2b,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:46 PM  wrote:
I tend to agree with Mollotchka. How can we welcome these immigrants into our land yet not give them the necessary means to survive in our society? If Americans are to welcome these peoples then it is our duty to educate them beyond the necessary classes that most natives could not answer!
kilomikelima,  on 06/17/2008 @ 09:54 PM  wrote:
You are right on target. I see so many comments that they HAVE to learn English. If we require it of immigrants, then we should support the requirement. Excellent!
samtaro,  on 06/18/2008 @ 11:57 AM  wrote:
I completely agree with you. Those who complain that immigrants do not speak the language, and yet oppose funding that could provide the opportunities to learn confuse me. If you want immigrants to assimilate, but your money where your mouth is, I say!
katrinaw345,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:10 PM  wrote:
I completely agree, but getting funding for that is not going to be easy. People aren't too quick to jump to help a foreign person. Every other industrialized country has programs like these, all but the US.
spiritloki,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:12 PM  wrote:
The majority of the problem isn't the fact that there is no support system...it's the fact that we as Americans cater to the immigrants, most especially mexican immigrants, by having English and Spanish signs and such. We make it easier for them to not have to learn English.
capitalbroad,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:25 PM  wrote:
In my opinion, the only way that we will be able to be a country that is not divided is to speak one language. I was born in this country and speak only english fluently and feel uncomfortable when a group is speaking a language that I don't understand. I am sure that immigrants feel this also.
Andyman2020,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:30 PM  wrote:
I think that they should be educated in how to speak English. I beleive they should be taught English and NOTHING else until they learn to be educated in English. No more science and math in spanish. AND after two years, if not fluent ship them back to wherever they came from
happyheratic,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:40 PM  wrote:
You bring up assimilation. It got me thinking. I wonder about this tendency to equate being American with assimilating to the "American lifestyle." I don't like the imagery of American as "melting pot" where every difference is melted into a goo. I prefer the image of America as a patchwork quilt--full of wonderful difference, complexity, and chaos yet underneath woven, and bound together by similiar values and dreams.
amyrun77,  on 06/18/2008 @ 12:57 PM  wrote:
I thought that we already helped immigrants with these things. I thought in order to become an American citizen you had to take classes and a citizenship exam. I also thought that many of these services were provided by our government free to immigrants.
jfjeter3,  on 06/18/2008 @ 01:32 PM  wrote:
I would love to see this happen, but in an environment where taxpayers are far more apt to complain about their taxes going to education than a misguided war, I don't hold out much hope.
JPJPaul,  on 06/18/2008 @ 01:45 PM  wrote:
There should also be programs by which immigrants are effectively registered as citiczens or temporary citiczens in this country. If they are going to live here, fine, be a part of our culture, fine, now they should help support it with taxes, wages, etc. If they want to be a part of this country, then help to keep it running.
nynekats,  on 06/18/2008 @ 01:53 PM  wrote:
For sure! The biggest thing too is that I feel they should have to pass a test to enter (when done legally) that shows that they know at least the basics. Keep your culture but learn ours as well!
chimmychonga,  on 06/18/2008 @ 01:53 PM  wrote:
It's certainly not an easy journey to the 'American Dream' for any immigrant but it could be made easier.
smartguy31,  on 06/18/2008 @ 01:59 PM  wrote:
The letter is not specific enough in identifying who it is reffering too. There could be multiple topics here.
KBref,  on 06/18/2008 @ 02:13 PM  wrote:
I agree with Benny Boy.... to become citizens you do have to take classes and just living here you will assimilate to the culture. If I chose to move to mexico, they aren't offering me any classes!
shschick40988,  on 06/18/2008 @ 02:26 PM  wrote:
Yes a thousand times! If people want to learn English in this country, especially since we make it hard for immigrants to survive without English, we should make instruction easily available.
Obamarama,  on 06/18/2008 @ 02:36 PM  wrote:
I agree very strongly with you Mollotchka. I'm so sick of hearing people bashing immigrants for failing to learn our customs when the real problem is that we don't, and really never have embraced them.
blossom4,  on 06/18/2008 @ 03:46 PM  wrote:
Agreed with BennyBoy, when going through citizenship you have to take tests and pass them in order to become a citizen. These involve learning about the most basic principles of our country and American culture.
steph777,  on 06/18/2008 @ 04:58 PM  wrote:
I think that our priority is just educating immigrants and teaching them how to speak and read english but the ones who are coming illegally should also have a way to learn so they stop being such a problem.
alenise,  on 06/18/2008 @ 05:16 PM  wrote:
If people choose not to learn the language of the land, they are asking to live at a certain level -- abject poverty. Any other nation would expect US citizenry to learn the language of the land before expecting any type of accommodation.
LanaMarlyce,  on 06/18/2008 @ 05:47 PM  wrote:
That is so true, because of the way most Americans look down on immigrants they aren't compelled to 'assimilate' and be like people around them. If there were better programs in place and awareness was raised i believe that immigrants would want to Americanize themselves
gas813,  on 06/18/2008 @ 07:29 PM  wrote:
I agree they should have an chance to learn english. But the question is do they want to learn and become part of our culture.
jennyibanez,  on 06/18/2008 @ 09:26 PM  wrote:
I agree with your point to a certain extent, the process whereby assimilating someone or a group takes years, and in order to become a citizen you are required to know certain information and have to take classes...so they meet others on the same boat so to speak-it;s not like they are just dropped off and released into the streets with no understanding of anything.
TommiG1506,  on 06/18/2008 @ 11:07 PM  wrote:
Although I agree that more government funded programs should be in place, I also must point out that most immigrants who become U.S citizens know more about our country than natural born citizens. I suggest more education on our country for ALL, immigrants and citizens alike
funnyjas03,  on 06/18/2008 @ 11:13 PM  wrote:
Everyone should be given an opportunity and this includes people who do not originate here. We need to help them all.
calife,  on 06/19/2008 @ 12:57 AM  wrote:
When immigrants come to this contry they should already be educated on our culture, laws, and language. The money we spend on education should go to our kids not to immigrants. - calife
Aloha1984,  on 06/19/2008 @ 06:29 AM  wrote:
They should be given a time limit. they should have 1 school year to be taught english. If thye dont know it. let them fend for themselves. if they fail school ship them back to their country
azliberal,  on 06/19/2008 @ 10:57 AM  wrote:
Citizenship is always an interesting subject for me. I live in Arizona so we have a large number of both legal and illegal immigrants. While i believe that all immigrants should do it the legal way, I also understand why they choose to do it illegally. the process to becoming a citizen is more than a little ridiculous. they expect the immigrant to know things about the country, its government, etc that most people born here don't know. There is no reason why they should need to know more than your average college grad. I believe that all illegal immigrants should be given the chance do it the right way. Put them through classes. those who do not or will not learn, send them back. But those willing to learn should at least be given the chance. Mind you, I don't think we should be trying to wipe out their culture entirely. That's not right.
calvin_makail1,  on 06/19/2008 @ 11:40 AM  wrote:
i think everyone who lives in and when to live in the states it should be mandantory to learn english!!!!!
KiaDiva8,  on 06/19/2008 @ 12:14 PM  wrote:
Adults should get the same attention and funding that collegebound students get, especially those who need to learn more about the American culture in order to dwell here.
AshCar,  on 06/19/2008 @ 12:41 PM  wrote:
I agree with you. There should be more support for legal immigrants in this country when it comes to language and culture. I know that they have to take citizenship classes to become citizens and they should really spend more time on the English language.
foozep23,  on 06/19/2008 @ 01:07 PM  wrote:
Oh My, I don't know where you live but I am from Boston and there are tons of programs to learn English. This is crazy talk, you must not be from a major city.
blu1224,  on 06/19/2008 @ 01:31 PM  wrote:
The reason there isn't funding for this type of education and support is based on the fact that the people who make these funding choices are the same people who aren't too happy with these "ethnics" coming to our country. They are the minute-men supporter types. This is my opinion based on the last eight years. People fear what they don't know.
lmikewhite,  on 06/19/2008 @ 01:39 PM  wrote:
You are right, but at the same time, immigrants need to want to learn our culture and language, and many do, but some do not.
Boylen33,  on 06/19/2008 @ 02:36 PM  wrote:
Your letter refers to legal immigrants. Unfortunately, the masses of immigrants in our country are not legal at all! We should spend our money on keeping them out of our country rather than educating and enabling them!
mw1221,  on 06/19/2008 @ 02:50 PM  wrote:
Immigrants indeed do need more help. We need to provide to them the same opportunities citizens have. They work harder than some citizens I know. We are a country representing freedom and opportunity. So lets give it to them.
celticdream11022,  on 06/19/2008 @ 03:21 PM  wrote:
There are plenty of resources out there but immigrants don't want to take advantage of them. They want to move here and make it just like their country. They need to learn how to be American.
pamphyila,  on 06/19/2008 @ 03:37 PM  wrote:
Yes, I think there is a definite need for some sort of classes/education for assimilation in American culture. I believe the Canadians do it - why not us?
mcpdontknow,  on 06/19/2008 @ 05:52 PM  wrote:
We don't need to spend money on educating immigrants when we have so many more important things to spend money on. If they wan't to come here they need to support themselves.
wnnrwnnrchckndnnr,  on 06/19/2008 @ 09:06 PM  wrote:
There are certainly some merits to your argument. But have you thought of illegal immigrants coming to the U.S. and having children here? Those children, though still technically illegal, are now legal citizens since they were born on U.S. property. That needs to be regulated a little better, but I agree in principle about treating LEGAL immigrants more fairly.
Awathu,  on 06/19/2008 @ 09:26 PM  wrote:
I think it's moreso up to the immigrants to learn English. America can only do so much. We already offer programs. It's just a matter of the immigrants taking advantage of them.
imaforevergirl,  on 06/20/2008 @ 11:59 AM  wrote:
i think that you have a point but i also think that if you had to go to china you might have a hard time fitting in...what ever happend to acceptance. We are amaericans we are all born to be brutes and not like what is different and for that we should be ashamed.
balanceheart,  on 06/20/2008 @ 03:22 PM  wrote:
This is a more complex issue than you are stating. I visited China and they gave me some information on what is legal and what isn’t. I took it upon myself to read it and learn about the country. There must be a balance here and one reason we are getting more aggressive with immigration is because where it is a huge problem the system is failing. More needs to be done but someone has to step up and start doing it.
PoliticalGirl,  on 06/20/2008 @ 06:25 PM  wrote:
We do need to accept newcomers with open arms instead of snubbed noses and obvious disdain.
kimlam45,  on 06/20/2008 @ 06:54 PM  wrote:
I agree with you. Good thing you brought it up. But remember immigrants cultures are different from American cultures. Remember not every culture allow their kids to come to a sleep over. Adding to that, they might not be interest in social groups because their main concern is to work to provide for their family. That's why they are here. However, I agree that there should be opportunities for immigrants that can help them feel welcome in a new country. I agree with adult education. What do you suggest?
theladyfatimah,  on 06/20/2008 @ 07:10 PM  wrote:
I think this should come from you and me. Americans need to reach out a welcoming hand, rather than to look at all immigrants with suspicion and bigotry.
morningfluff,  on 06/20/2008 @ 07:25 PM  wrote:
Everyone in a place where they do not speak the major language has the instant opportunity to learn that language by simply living immersed in that language. People who never learn a word of English in this country don't learn English because they don't have to. In fact, they are being provided the opportunity not to.
Tidefan,  on 06/20/2008 @ 09:59 PM  wrote:
Better services for legal immigrants makes sense. But how do we pay for it? Is this a policy best left for government or non-profit service organizations?
Antonius,  on 06/21/2008 @ 05:29 AM  wrote:
I don't necessarily think there needs to be more funding. I think there needs to be more awareness. People need to reach out to these immigrants, not shun them. It needs to be more of a community project than a government project.
dannydp,  on 06/21/2008 @ 06:14 AM  wrote:
There are tons of programs for legal immigrants coming into the country to take advantage of for learning english, learning our customs, and in general helping our community rather than hurting it. The problem is most don't bother with these programs. THey do what they need to to become a citizen and then expect us to take care of there problems. It's a sad state. 50 years ago, 100 years ago, when the Irish and Italians came in, you didn't see this. People studied, they learned how to interact with our society. This was before most of the current programs were even available. It's sad really.
Jew_Bagel,  on 06/21/2008 @ 06:43 AM  wrote:
It seems to me that those choosing not to assimilate aren't the legal immigrants, rather the illegal immigrants and I believe they suck up enough public resources as is.
angelseeker,  on 06/21/2008 @ 07:12 AM  wrote:
When my grandparents imigrated to this country, they made their own effort to assimilate. They learned the language and became Americans. It seems far too many of today's immigrants don't want to make any effort.
dmullenbach,  on 06/21/2008 @ 07:47 AM  wrote:
Legal immigrants already do take classes on "how to be American". It is illegal immigrants and people just visiting the country that are having so much trouble.
qwerty123,  on 06/21/2008 @ 08:53 AM  wrote:
I agree with that. On another note, when you see a second generation American here, aren't they pretty well assimilated. I do understand how frustrating it is to hear someone speaking English, but I think in the long run the system works.
nanfd,  on 06/21/2008 @ 09:20 AM  wrote:
You tell then Mollotchka!!! As the child of legal immigrants I watched my parents struggle to put food on the table week to week. My mom's English got better because she would read every book assigned to me in school and she would do all of the phonics and English homework with me. We could not afford night school or private English classes.
rustymagic,  on 06/21/2008 @ 10:40 AM  wrote:
Leagal Immigrants should indeed learn English prior to or soon after entering the states. This should also be under thier own dime. There are poeple all over this country who speak English and many outlets for learning. Legal Immigrants need to get out of the subgroups where they are surrounded by people who speak thier own language.
Right_WingNut,  on 06/21/2008 @ 12:19 PM  wrote:
While I do not believe that we need to provide adult education and immigrant support services, I believe we must do everything in our power to assist immigrants who want to become Americans. If this means establishing English as our official language, then so be it. (Granted, the citizenship exam must be completed in English. But, we would be fools to believe that this is sufficient to encourage all immigrants to learn to read/write/speak English.
KAY9,  on 06/21/2008 @ 04:49 PM  wrote:
WE NEED MORE FUNDING TO EDUCATE AND SUPPORT OR OWN! I TOLERATE FOREIGNORS BECAUSE WE MAY NEED THEM FOR OUR ALLIES, BUT REALLY KEEP THEM IN THEIR OWN COUNTRIES AND DEVELOPE THEM INSTEAD OF TAKING ALL OUR RESOURCES
wildermommiex3,  on 06/21/2008 @ 05:10 PM  wrote:
When legal immagrants come to this country, and I know this from a "legal" immagrant family member, you take a study on our country kind of like american history if you will. If they choose to take an english course the price can be reimbersed.
dawn25ny,  on 06/21/2008 @ 07:03 PM  wrote:
I agree with you, if there were a stronger support system in place for those who came here legally we would not be complaining that people do not know how to speak our language. It has to be hard enough being in a strange country, why can't we welcome them and teach them!
cyn_stevie,  on 06/21/2008 @ 10:25 PM  wrote:
I am a teacher taking classes to become ESL endorsed. I work with Second Language Learners daily and agree that there needs to be more support in the areas you addressed in your letter. I think that more needs to be done internationally to impact the North American economy. I think that NATO should pass an international minimum wage, so those in other countries don't have to make the decision that leads them here illegally. The poverty that exists in our bordering Latin countries is obscene, and more ought to be done for those who aren't as fortunate to migrate, legally or illegally.
PJBess,  on 06/22/2008 @ 12:31 AM  wrote:
This is so wrong. People have been coming to American for over 200 years. Immigrants learned English in all generations. They did not need funding and support services. They had a desire to learn. They wanted to assimilate.
moocow,  on 06/22/2008 @ 01:04 AM  wrote:
Although I agree with you, I don't think that this is exclusive to immigrants. Everyone should have access to affordable education.
1stevecy,  on 06/22/2008 @ 11:20 AM  wrote:
I am also getting my ESL endorsement. The reason for stronger support for education is connected to the consequences for not educating them. I also think that bilingual education is the key to success. In 70 years White English only speaking people will not be able to get the types of job that someone with the gift of bilingualism has. We are shooting ourselves in the foot if we don't support and learn the language of our immigrants.
vedderpj857,  on 06/22/2008 @ 01:29 PM  wrote:
sure we should educatreeeveryone. no one should ever be denied that. who is to say what one should and should not l;earn...screw this place sometimes...-vedderpj857
tehf00f,  on 06/23/2008 @ 11:10 PM  wrote:
Hear hear! The better we educate those within our communities, the stronger and more successful we will all be.
arkjarhead,  on 06/24/2008 @ 02:27 AM  wrote:
I think you are wrong. They need to know english before they come here. I get tired of hearing them talk their gibberish everywhere I go.
randjdona,  on 06/24/2008 @ 04:32 AM  wrote:
I think they should have to go through a program in their own country before they come here and we americans are not footing the bill.
CDep55,  on 06/24/2008 @ 10:48 AM  wrote:
There are plenty of oppurtunitys out there to learn english. They need to earn the money for it. I wouldent go to another country and ask them to teach me there language.
bethebutton,  on 06/29/2008 @ 07:57 PM  wrote:
like i said in an earlier post, THERE ARE BIGGER FISH TO FRY
bethebutton,  on 06/29/2008 @ 07:59 PM  wrote:
LIKE I SAID I AN EARLIER POST, THERE ARE MUCH BIGGER FISH TO FRY... THIS IS A DISTRACTION ISSUE FROM THE REAL PROBLEMS IN AMERICA
vhmehta,  on 07/02/2008 @ 06:06 AM  wrote:
Legal immigrants have to know about US before becoming citizen. I don't think we as taxpayers should waste our money on illegal immigrants (criminals).
tesla2010,  on 07/02/2008 @ 07:37 AM  wrote:
There needs to be more intiative on the part of the immigrants to use the education and support services that exist. They are already funded, and if the letter writer would dare to venture into "their" neighborhoods, you would find resoruces for them. Resources they shun because they are ignorant, lazy, or scared. Why whould they work hard at assimilating, they movd to America to be lazy and lay around like the Americans they see on TV reality shows.
shnigg,  on 07/03/2008 @ 07:45 AM  wrote:
Great article. I feel that as every person is created equal there needs to be a system of allowing everyone to learn English. This is not only a good skill to have in America, but anywhere you go. If everyone was recognized as a person then we would all be happier. There are illegal immigrants who pay taxes and do not even see the benefit. There has to be a better way to treat people be they legal or illegal. We are in the end just people and if we want to remain we need to help each other.
Cilantro,  on 07/03/2008 @ 11:33 AM  wrote:
I think it's great to help people feel more at home and give them more opportunities.
jessicalyn21,  on 07/08/2008 @ 08:55 AM  wrote:
Whenever immigrants are talked about, the majority of people first assumes that we are talking about illegal immigrants. There are so many legal immigrants in the United States that are doing everything the right and legal way and don't receive help in assimilating to this country. For examples, I actually have quite a few friends that came to the United States as children and were put straight into ESL (English as a Second Language) courses. The funny thing about this name is that many of them didn't learn English in their classes, but continued to speak Spanish, Mandarin and Tagalog in the classroom. I've also had immigant friends that knew English, but were forced to stay in ESL classes that had a much lower education standard, putting these students behind students the same age. I complete agree that there needs to be more help to immigrants coming to this country.
wiggle_worm7,  on 07/09/2008 @ 11:37 AM  wrote:
It is disheartening to see English as a second language at my son's grade school. I am not bilingual--I was taught the language of the land. If somebody is going to immigrate to the U.S., they should take every opportunity to learn the language as their burden, and not burden the rest of the English-Speaking population of America with trying to teach them our language. I would not go to another country and expect to be given language lessons by that country, and I don't feel we should do it, either.
edithbx,  on 07/11/2008 @ 08:02 PM  wrote:
I've worked in several emerging democratic countries, and from first hand experience I know that the best way for a country to create a strong sense of patriotism and responsibility in its citizens is to provide them with access to a decent education. Educating everyone at a basic standard will make American strong in the long run.
chowhuahua,  on 07/13/2008 @ 09:34 AM  wrote:
I think there are plenty of opportunities for ESL, they are just not being chosen. I for one am sick of having to press one for English. In America. What is the OFFICIAL language here?
rebecca9588,  on 07/14/2008 @ 08:00 PM  wrote:
Well said. I don't think that people realize how long and how hard it is to learn another language. The classes offered in English are just the tip of the iceberg. It takes, as studies have shown, about 5 years of intense training to learn another language to the point of being functional in an academic setting. Hard to do when you are working, taking care of a family etc. I have personal knowledge that many would jump at this chance if given.
DROID,  on 07/16/2008 @ 08:01 AM  wrote:
Let's just keep it all the same. It has worked for years just fine. They sneak over hear and we pretend to not notice. They work in jobs that we won't work in. And they build there communities amongst themselves. Who cares if they can't speak English. All the more reason not to talk to them.
hekare,  on 07/19/2008 @ 03:04 PM  wrote:
K12 schools have to take everyone regardless of immigration status. As for adults, there doesn't seem to be any shortage of la raza groups who could support new immigrants, but it doesn't seem that their priority is helping people become Americans.
bienaimee2,  on 07/29/2008 @ 07:08 AM  wrote:
I agree that there should be more support of people that want to come to our country (even at this point in our country's lifetime). But I feel that leagal immigrants do have quite a few oppurtunities to not only learn English, but learn about our country's history...I think, forgive me if I'm wrong, but it's part of the naturalization process.
greenrichard,  on 07/31/2008 @ 01:46 PM  wrote:
I agree that there should be a support network, but I think the immigrants should take matters into their own hands and build it themselves. Learn by doing.
whoisjohngalt,  on 08/05/2008 @ 08:11 AM  wrote:
The immigrants should be allowed to come here, but they should have the burden of learning English placed upon themselves. It is not the state that should have the burden of the cost.
alize4eddington,  on 08/07/2008 @ 02:36 PM  wrote:
They are willing to learn so why not give them a chance . Just open up more doors and they will show you they to can help their lives, communities, and America
Herrings,  on 09/14/2008 @ 05:44 PM  wrote:
Government has no obligation to provide education to people who choose to come into the country. If they can't speak the language and know nothing about the culture then they shouldn't elect to come here.
jessforturk,  on 09/14/2008 @ 07:52 PM  wrote:
I cannot quite grasp the idea of an american insisting that we reach out and help immigrants when there are other issues that need to be addressed. What about the fact that one in four veterans is homeless? Why would we reach out and help illegals to acclaimate themselves to our culture when there are veterans who have yet to master that?
Sean_Heffernan,  on 09/30/2008 @ 06:13 PM  wrote:
Hatred for immigrants is so laced with racism its undeniable. People get so passionate about immigration because they hate Mexicans and history will look back upon them as bigots and fools. We need a humane immigration policy that will assimilate and educate.
ami_71,  on 10/03/2008 @ 08:00 PM  wrote:
I agree with you 100%. This country has always been ignorant about how to deal with immigrants. This is definitely the truth.
rubypie,  on 10/04/2008 @ 06:20 PM  wrote:
I totally agree! There needs to be a bridge and there isn't and adults and their children suffer when they enter into this country from a non English speaking country. I'm all for this implementation.
rlam,  on 10/08/2008 @ 08:26 PM  wrote:
I agree that immigrants should be taught our language and culture, its a good way to see how the USA works. If they welcome and enjoy the life here that's great. They wont form gangs because they feel as they are picked on.
Lisa72,  on 11/03/2008 @ 11:44 PM  wrote:
I know several people that have gone through our immigration process. It is a very impersonal process. They are taught the basics of our nation, but more in a way that we are taught basic math skills in school. They memorize facts rather than learn. They need current citizens to help and teach them on a daily basis. It's like putting a child that doesn't know how to read in a room full of books, surrounded by information but no way to interpret it. Now add a person that knows how to read and you soon will have a scholar.
thegrey,  on 11/11/2008 @ 08:02 PM  wrote:
NO!NO!NO! Enough is enough! Spending taxpayer dollars on people who are not citizens is bankrupting our system! Our schools are already stretched beyond their limits, as are our teachers. Let them do as my ancestors did, learn Engllish on their own time.
merritt911,  on 11/21/2008 @ 02:35 AM  wrote:
There should be more education provided to those that come to this country. I believe at the end of the day it does nothing but make this country better.
abender,  on 12/01/2008 @ 02:03 PM  wrote:
This is a great way to help with the transition into America. There is nothing wrong with keeping hold of tradition, but learning the language of your new home is essential to making the most of your experience here. Great idea!
acx2009,  on 12/01/2008 @ 06:05 PM  wrote:
that is so true! even though i have immigrant parents and they have done quite fine in learning the language and everything, it does seem like it would be pretty hard. I actually have an aunt who has lived here for 8 years and can barely speak english, if there was a better welcoming program then maybe she would
jcsmartz,  on 12/04/2008 @ 09:18 AM  wrote:
I agree that individuals, not just immigrants need to be educated but I don't agree that we should create programs based upon the funneling of money from US citizens. If what you say is true, than I believe there should be some from of taxation on illegal immigration or accept the illegals but give them citizenry and a number to identify for tax purposes.
flightlessplague,  on 01/04/2009 @ 04:26 AM  wrote:
I agree that immigrants should be educated, but who says they need to assimilate. What is this "American" culture? We have always been a nation of many different cultures and the melting pot of the world. It's a beautiful thing that theres so many cultures. Obviously, learning basic things like laws and English is a must, but to strip one of their identity is barbaric.
kfleming78,  on 01/04/2009 @ 07:40 AM  wrote:
I will say that most illegal immigrants do speak english. However, they don't want to speak it with us! I know hundreds of Mexicans and from my experience 99 out of 100 can communicate just fine in english, they just don't want to speak it with Americans. I think a better option would be to teach Americans how to stop being prejudice
blackjack,  on 01/04/2009 @ 08:21 PM  wrote:
While I agree with your letter, during these hard economic times, what will/would you cut from a budget to fund these additional programs. Not that there isn't fluff to be cut from most political budgets, but that's always the first question raised.
Coolrunning62985,  on 01/10/2009 @ 03:22 PM  wrote:
I think that most immigrants have chances to assimilate to our culture, but are unwilling to. This is an issue where both sides have to want the assimilation process to occur.
Bigfattie_69,  on 01/11/2009 @ 07:30 PM  wrote:
I am in complete concord. It must be very difficult to assimilate to a new culture, country and llaws without the help and assistance of that government. There should definitely be programs to help these brave people.
carigis,  on 01/17/2009 @ 01:17 PM  wrote:
I do agree the immigrants MUST learn english to come to this country. Otherwise we just get mini communities and noone mixes. However, the government should NOT be the one paying for it.. learn english on your own first.. or dont come
suomichris,  on 01/18/2009 @ 09:15 AM  wrote:
This is a major problem than many people with "English-only" or "anti-immigrant" views don't understand. Where I live, there is currently a TWO YEAR wait to get into any ESL class, not to mention the free, public-service classes.
kristena,  on 01/18/2009 @ 08:19 PM  wrote:
I've been a part of very organized groups that help Vietnamese and Romanian immigrants get help with language classes, transportation, and other services provided in their new country. I am not quite sure what you are talking about, but some families and cultures choose to retain their religion, appaarel, music, and ethnic friends.
anguiano,  on 01/23/2009 @ 07:43 AM  wrote:
I'm going to assume that my ignorance comes from the fact that I've only lived in cities. I have never lived in rural parts of this country so maybe that's where this letter of concern is coming from. Or maybe the immigrants this person is talking about are the people who's language isn't popular and so are not given as many opportunities. Again I'm admitting that I'm speaking from ignorance. However, I know that in cities (and i've moved around this great land of ours to know it's not just the one i'm living in) there are lots of places where English is taught as a second language; where "buddies" are set up with families so that they would have an American friend/advocate who would help them with grocery shopping for example, government papers, and teach American culture; and I've even noticed that American culture all depends on where you live and therefore isn't something to learn.
cucumberblind,  on 01/26/2009 @ 06:09 PM  wrote:
I agree that immigrants need to be fully accepted as an integral part of the American culture. We are a country created through immigration and yet now we reject those who continue the legacy.
hendo1843,  on 01/26/2009 @ 07:50 PM  wrote:
While I agree that immigrant should pursue education I do not agree that it should be in anyway funded by the government.
surfer613,  on 01/28/2009 @ 07:54 PM  wrote:
I think that it is largely the responsibility of immigrants to assimilate, however I do agree that programs that teach English would be helpful for them to learn our culture, etc.
cakoen,  on 02/07/2009 @ 11:09 AM  wrote:
I'd love for there to be assimilation programs for immigrants who come here legally. Language barriers are not only inconvenient, but can sometimes be life threatening should a crisis arise. On the flip side, we should also put more emphasis on foreign language in our schools so that we can better communicate with people coming into our country who might not have a firm grasp on English yet. It goes both ways.
samgomez,  on 02/09/2009 @ 12:07 AM  wrote:
i didnt like the title "educating immigrants" but i am a new citizen, and im a legal immigrant and do beleive there should be more funding for adult education and immigrant support services. luckily i learned all of this on my own but know of ppl who rly couldnt do that on their own.
justaminute4,  on 02/11/2009 @ 09:44 PM  wrote:
It is terrifically ironic that so many would present an unfriendly, closed wall to immigrants for fear of their being different delay their assimilation with that very wall.
jdoty9,  on 02/15/2009 @ 01:20 PM  wrote:
They shouldn't be provided with these basic courses after they have arrived to our country. They should and are proved with these courses during the process of becoming a legal citizen. Illegal immigrants should not be provided with funded courses as they will again be living for free off of our government.
cool,  on 02/18/2009 @ 05:55 PM  wrote:
The immigrants need to be definitely educated about the language, laws and culture.More and more campaigns are to be held.
DeeZiredone08,  on 03/05/2009 @ 09:49 PM  wrote:
It's always been that way with immigrants, it's part of the struggle with coming to a new country. If we where to go to a different country, we'd have to take it upon ourselves to learn the language. Just because we are the United States doesnt mean, we should go above and beyond in the situation. Im sorry I disagree.
edlinux,  on 03/13/2009 @ 04:34 AM  wrote:
i agree whit you immigrants need to learn english and get educated
mitch,  on 03/13/2009 @ 06:09 PM  wrote:
In the emotional climate today we have to be very careful with these types of thing. Many times this is seen as trying to make these immigrants "turn their backs " on their own culture. Most adults are either unwilling, unable, or simply don't have the time to do this.
maschlau,  on 03/24/2009 @ 08:14 PM  wrote:
The citizenship classes teach you some of the basics, but heck our own school system doesn't begin to teach people about being an American or your legal rights. Although I have little faith in our public schools somehow improving this, I do believe bilingual education should be founded on allowing immigrants to keep their distinct culture, but also teaching them not only what American culture is, but why they need to learn it.
hollyfigueroa,  on 04/05/2009 @ 05:33 PM  wrote:
Agreed. Opportunities need to be available, and to my knowledge, they are largely available on the coasts and in larger cities. Maybe not in the middle of the country as much, and that needs to change.
eldonjon72,  on 06/13/2009 @ 09:48 AM  wrote:
No, they should learn before they come here. My tax dollars barely cover the education of my own kids, don't use that money to educate someone who didn't have the foresight to think ahead that "oh yeah, maybe I'll need to know the language if I'm going to move there". DUH
carrieeebaby,  on 06/24/2009 @ 01:47 PM  wrote:
I never really thought of the issue that way. I always tended to be against immigration, but now I realize that was very close minded.

Home   |   Who We Are   |   Issues   |   Letters   |   Search   |   API   |   News   |   Official Blog   |   Donate!   |   Signup   |   Login

Copyright © 2006 - 2010 Freedom Speaks LLC. All Rights Reserved.    Terms & Conditions   |   Privacy Policy

Total Request Time: 00.0000 Seconds
Machine Name: KMG-INT02

Share this Page!   Share this page on Digg Share this page on Delicious Share this page on Facebook Share this page on Furl Share this page on Google Share this page on Windows Live Spaces Share this page on Magnolia Share this page on Netscape Share this page on Newsvine Share this page on Reddit Share this page on Slashdot Share this page on Samrking Share this page on StumbleUpon Share this page on Technorati Share this page on Yahoo!