America Desperately Needs a High-Skilled Labor Force!

Related Issues:  Foreign Policy , Science / Technology , Illegal Immigration

Tags:  immigration , h1b , high skilled labor , visas , skil act

This Letter Targets:  Representative Nancy Pelosi , Representative Steny H. Hoyer , Representative John Conyers, Jr. , Representative Roy Blunt , Representative John A. Boehner , Representative Lamar Smith

Tuesday, 04/22/2008 @ 04:00 PM PST
To whom it may concern:

We respectfully request that you bring to the House floor, within the next few months of 2008, legislation increasing temporary, high-skilled, legal immigration to the United States.

In the past, the issue of temporary, high skilled, legal immigration has been linked politically and legislatively to the issue of illegal immigration. We believe this linkage to be unfortunate at best and urge you to decouple the issues by moving temporary, high-skilled, legal immigration reform legislation to the floor in short order.

Every year, American businesses tell us how they are unable to retain the qualified people that they want to retain because of the artificially low H-1B visas caps and related regulations that do not reflect market realities. This situation is ironic, since most of these unemployable people were educated in the United States. As a country we are effectively handing these highly-educated, extremely desirable individuals a diploma and a plane ticket. The message we are sending is: "You can learn here, but you have to work in another country."

According to an annual survey by the National Opinion Research Center at the University of Chicago, foreign born students holding temporary visas received 33% of all research doctorates awarded by U.S. universities in 2006 - up from 25% in 2001. Foreign students comprised 44% of science and engineering doctorates in 2006. Yet in the last five years, the 65,000 H-1B visa quota has been exhausted nearly as soon as the applications became available in April of each year, leaving tens of thousands of well-educated, skilled professionals with no choice but to work in another country. American businesses have responded by hiring other people they believe are less qualified or by placing the migrants off-shore so that they can retain the people they really want.

Either way, America loses.

For example, in 2007, Microsoft opened a facility in Vancouver, British Columbia, exclusively to put to work foreign-born employees for Microsoft was unable to procure H-1B visas. This was a first for Microsoft, since it had always done its product development in the United States. The Microsoft employees in Vancouver are from all around the world and would otherwise be employed in Washington State but for the federal government's inability to provide an adequate number of visas.

Craig Barrett, Chairman of the Intel Corporation, which has about 2,000 employees with H-1B visas, points to an increasingly trend of foreign-born professionals - even those who have lived in the United States for years and have graduated from American universities - considering opportunities in competitor nations. "With Congress gridlocked on immigration, it's clear that the next Silicon Valley will not be in the United States," wrote Mr. Bennett.

Given this growing problem that hampers the freedoms of our businesses to hire and retain whom they want when they want, we urge you to bring to the House floor legislation that would increase - even if temporarily - the flow of high-skilled, legal immigrants into this country.

An example of such legislation is H.R. 1930, the Securing Knowledge, Innovation, and Leadership Act of 2007 (SKIL Act), which would increase the H-1B visa cap from 65,000 to 115,000 and provide for a 20% increase in the cap for each year that the previous year's quota is reached. H.R. 1930 would also make several needed reforms to the program, such as exempting from the annual H-1B visa cap an immigrant who has earned a master's or higher degree from an accredited U.S. university or has been awarded a medical specialty certification based on post-doctoral training and experience in the United States.

America has the ability to attract and keep the best talent in the world for our companies - but only if we stop turning away so many qualified professionals at the door. Thank you for your consideration, and I look forward to your response.

Sincerely,
Jason
View All    |   Sort by Newest First
Letter Comments
Total Comments: 50
lectersmeal,  on 04/25/2008 @ 04:38 PM PST  wrote:
I couldn't agree more with your letter. In fact, I never knew the difficulty of maintaining (*skilled*) immigrants.
BennyBoy,  on 05/01/2008 @ 12:47 AM PST  wrote:
We'll just keep losing companies to other countries if this isn't fixed...
JM4Change,  on 05/13/2008 @ 04:53 PM PST  wrote:
I agree, but this is also an indicator of a larger issue. America is losing its edge in technical and scientific innovation. Multiples more engineers come out of India and China than the US; meanwhile, our best and brightest go to Ivy League schools to be educated on the stock market, which doesn't help our future prospects at all. This is why we need to bring in foreign workers to begin with, and it is a big problem if you ask me. Engineering and sciences are not "sexy" positions, and don't offer huge salaries or potential growth. So, we do need to be aggressive in keeping skilled workers from abroad.
feWill,  on 05/29/2008 @ 04:31 PM PST  wrote:
We should do all that we can to get skilled labor here. We should be more open to immigration.
Harley20,  on 05/31/2008 @ 05:49 PM PST  wrote:
What about educating American to be skilled in the areas needed instead of relying on people from other countries?
phmcd,  on 06/05/2008 @ 05:57 AM PST  wrote:
Kind of goes back to the letter about illegal immigration. We need an educated workforce.
Jason,  on 06/05/2008 @ 10:39 AM PST  wrote:
Harley20 - Americans have more opportunities than anyone else in the world to become a skilled worker. If someone wants to be a software engineer or neurosurgeon, they can if they work hard enough. In the case of software, however, there is way too much demand right now and not enough workers.
MadScience,  on 06/11/2008 @ 12:19 PM PST  wrote:
You make some valid points - but as a scientist I know that there are many unemployed, American citizen scientists who cannot find a job. Why not educate these already-trained scientists to better be able to compete in the domestic workforce?
hoppingviola,  on 06/13/2008 @ 04:05 PM PST  wrote:
Frequently congress is way too slow to fix things that are obvious and easy fixes. These bits of legislation would be an easy way to escape that problem.
lovelymrw,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:01 AM PST  wrote:
I think if we make it manadatory that anyone 18 or older must have a high school diploma in order to receive a liscence or that anyone receiving public service can only be on it two to three years and must have a fulltime job or be in school fulltime in order to receive any of the services. We could create a great work force in this country. We keep looking for greater outside this country....like when we buy foreign cars, yet we forget that the people in this country need income in order to support this countries economy, so if we don't invest in our own, we can't expect anything better
rdgoldean,  on 06/17/2008 @ 07:51 AM PST  wrote:
I think college attendance is now at the highest percentage ever in America. Of course, education is only one aspect of a skilled work force. Training is also very critical.
Jeskel83,  on 06/17/2008 @ 08:00 AM PST  wrote:
This work force sucks because americans cant compete will the mexicans working for less money at a harder rate. They can do this because they live with the whole family and share all bills, so they can make money here and go to there country and live big. The action needed is to reform americans willing to learn that yeah maybe you have to pay a little more but it will help in the long run. As a small business owner I had a huge problem finding quality people to work for me and other small places of business stuggle as well.
Sanonymous35,  on 06/18/2008 @ 11:44 PM PST  wrote:
The drop out rate has increased considerably. May students returning to secondary education are lacking basic skills in math and language.
Rgonzalez,  on 06/19/2008 @ 12:18 PM PST  wrote:
Most people in this country are so full of themselves, even the poor would rather sit on their butts at home and collect SSI, or welfare than go do the jobs that millions of immigrants are so eager to risk their lives to come do for us. We need them back...
balanceheart,  on 06/20/2008 @ 03:27 PM PST  wrote:
Attracting talent is a major thing right now for many countries. America is falling behind here with immigrants as well as educating its own people. These factors are already bringing attention to these systems as they need updating.
ecacofonix,  on 06/20/2008 @ 10:37 PM PST  wrote:
America has become the force it is simply because it did not fear knowledge from outside. It has become a superpower by creating a framework that attracts the best in the world. But the H1B quotas are against this principle and are simply retrograde. They produce short-term gains but erode the very principles that made the country great
miss617x,  on 06/21/2008 @ 09:37 AM PST  wrote:
This is way beyond an immigration issue. This is a USA issue - how many college graduates actually use their degree? It's like it's a social status symbol, yet they stay at their "comfortable" jobs, making no money, mooching for life.. The issue is far deeper than what you say.
renrag,  on 06/21/2008 @ 12:43 PM PST  wrote:
I agree that legal immigration is something that america was built on and shouldn't be confused with illegal immigration. But I don't agree with more H1-B visas, I think they are a way for companies in america to legitimately get away with hiring someone for less pay. Why would a company in america when they see the economic struggle that we are going through and the jobless claims not hire americans? Please don't use the Bush arguement of "jobs americans aren't willing to do". There are thoudands of college graduates every year in this country and millions of blue collar workers. I think you could find someone "skilled" to fill your positions.
Growls,  on 06/22/2008 @ 06:37 AM PST  wrote:
Well said, I hope you'll let us all know if you get a response. This is really well done and an important issue that few know about.
adegca,  on 06/22/2008 @ 12:40 PM PST  wrote:
The ability of employers to do this makes them feel okay laying off citizen-workers just to hire (& train further) imported workers. We need to employ & train our own.
cynsear,  on 06/22/2008 @ 05:00 PM PST  wrote:
American cannot compete in a global economy without addressing the need for an educated, competent work force. This is a good first step.
sabrahardy,  on 06/29/2008 @ 06:55 AM PST  wrote:
FIRST EDUCATED AMERICANS
BiffTouchdown,  on 06/30/2008 @ 02:20 AM PST  wrote:
Yes, we need skilled workers. But why should we try to rely on foreigners? The United States state of science education is worse than the Dark Ages - just by knowing how to install an operating system, I am the technology god of my neighborhood, family, and company. Every time I hear one of our own citizens say "I barely know how to turn a computer on!" I want to brain myself with a shovel. Why should an India-educated programmer even bother moving to the US at all, if this is what they get when they get here?
Jason,  on 06/30/2008 @ 10:17 AM PST  wrote:
sabrahardy - I believe you have only reinforced my argument. Software engineers can make over $100K / year, but a good deal of discipline is needed. I'm not finding too many of those lately. It's sad, really. Regardless, the talent pool here in the US has dried up, and we need to bring it in quickly to meet demand.
mystermyke1,  on 07/05/2008 @ 11:30 PM PST  wrote:
Jason, Your submission of this topic on freedomspeaks.com is highly complex. We have the best schools. Many immigrants get school visas to come here and learn. there not taking over the college enrollment. Many of the finest doctor in pittsburgh are forgien. Many U.S. born skilled workers dont leave the country because of economics, they want to explore the world. i love your post. and i will continue to read it until i fully understand
DanDannoodle,  on 07/13/2008 @ 11:52 AM PST  wrote:
Absolutely. The world economy is moving into a stage where "human capital" is becoming increasingly important compared to land, resources or factories. It's the countries that are able to secure the most innovators and well-educated workers that will succeed in this new globalized economy. By preventing high-skilled workers from entering the company, we're just shooting ourselves in the foot.
terrywilson94,  on 08/10/2008 @ 02:34 PM PST  wrote:
We need to start at preschool, we are not doing our kids any favors, I work with 2nd through 8th graders and many can not do basic math, reading or writing. I would go with the Europe's schools.
gurugirl,  on 08/29/2008 @ 05:34 PM PST  wrote:
The problem that I have with this is that we should be training people in the US to do these jobs, and encouraging the policies in other countries that would give their citizens work opportunities that we should not provide. American workers and educated skilled Americans should be the top priority for corporations. College graduates should not have to compete with foreign workers for what few jobs are left in this country because someone will take less pay. My husband currently works with H-1B immigrants that take less pay at his company, bringing down his wage as well. What he should get $75 and hour for he gets $40, with all his education (Masters Degree going for PHD), and all his student loans it seems really unfair. Fix American jobs first then worry about foreign workers
1isSm0ked,  on 08/30/2008 @ 02:50 PM PST  wrote:
Made in America by Proud Americans should be on everyone's agenda. Americans have become apathetic and lazy and creating NAFTA was a huge mistake. Americans now have the choice of buying Chinese junk, Taiwan trash or Mexican mistakes and it is our own fault. Wake up America and get off your lazy asses and be proud to work. God bless. 1isSmoked
ASTERION,  on 10/23/2008 @ 03:30 PM PST  wrote:
Better to attract them here than losing to them as work gets outsourced indeed!
KateB,  on 11/16/2008 @ 08:07 PM PST  wrote:
A high-skilled labor force that is imported will be a hard sell with the current economy. A better idea would be incentives to develop same in the CONUS.
pproanalyst,  on 11/24/2008 @ 12:24 AM PST  wrote:
Yes we do need to address the lack of highly skilled talent in the US. Not only do we need to increase the H-1B Visa cap, but we need to direct more of our young people into the sciences and tech skills at an early age. We need to have move of our young people earn PhD degrees, rather than looking for a fast dollar!
crafty55,  on 01/03/2009 @ 01:57 AM PST  wrote:
not only do i agree with this letter, i wish more people were aware of the situation. I am new to s. calif and all i hear about is the horrors of illegal immigrants, and even with the low skilled labor force, all i see is hard working people who are more then willing to pick up the shovels and the jobs that many have turned their backs on. our country was built on the principle of immigration, instead of being afraid of it, its time to incorporate it, legislate it, and let it work for us in ways to help the economy and to grow as a stronger nation. the fact that major us industries have to open up facilities in canada to work around our laws does not compute or make sense one response was to educate our own, you have to HAVE the people that want to learn in the first place! thank you for opening my eyes to one more reality of the immigration situation.
jrj102,  on 01/03/2009 @ 10:54 PM PST  wrote:
I completely agree. The same folks who are saying we need to eliminate or reduce H1Bs also say we need to restrict outsourcing. This would cripple the ability of American businesses to compete on the world stage. (I should probably disclose that I work for a company that employs a large number of H-1B immigrants.)
synergy3000,  on 01/18/2009 @ 08:33 AM PST  wrote:
Our immigration policy has been to accept illegal immigrants (unofficially f course) to do the cheap menial labor. Instead lets allow skilled educated workers into the US and encourage them to stay and grow our economy. More engineers means more machines being built to do the job that illegal immigrants instead do. Those illegals then send US dollars out of the country causing further harm.
annemarie,  on 01/19/2009 @ 01:37 PM PST  wrote:
yeah Your right!!
cassandra_jones,  on 01/28/2009 @ 08:27 AM PST  wrote:
I agree to some level, but I think that aside from just a skilled workforce we also need available job positions. There just aren`t enough jobs to go around, so even if the employees of America are highly skilled, where are they supposed to implement those skills?
oakman,  on 01/28/2009 @ 11:21 AM PST  wrote:
The United States has plenty of highly skilled , technically savy, people who are without work. Many of them were replaced by less-skilled imported workers who primary advantage to their employer was that they were willing to work for slave wages. We should close down the H1B program and give these foreign workers the heave-ho.
Brownorino152,  on 02/27/2009 @ 11:21 PM PST  wrote:
I agree, there is no reason we should not at least put some effort into not falling behind the software department. Good aurgument
stockton,  on 03/04/2009 @ 03:12 PM PST  wrote:
There are plenty of skilled professionals out of work. Some companies don't want to pay fair wages instead preferring to hire foreigners who will work 70 hrs a week live in relative squalor, work for peanuts and keep it zipped. The shortage is pure fantasy.
Hawa,  on 03/25/2009 @ 11:21 AM PST  wrote:
I agree, but why can't americans start obtaining these skills. So many people rely on education and credentials but when it all falls down, its those that work with their hands that the country will look to to pick up the pieces
spiderlaw,  on 03/27/2009 @ 03:12 PM PST  wrote:
Right on! I can't stand to see the poor excuse of an education our high schools now give. As don't mean anything but that someone's parents were pushy. We need more science, technology, and math education for sure. But we also can't leave out english, writing, and creative activities lest we become a nation of bots.
afsweb,  on 04/04/2009 @ 08:29 PM PST  wrote:
Immigration should be much easier. I don't see why we need to restrict the smart from becoming Americans. I personally see far too many Americans take jobs for which they really are unqualified for.
enigma0,  on 04/10/2009 @ 01:59 PM PST  wrote:
You're now a foe. Nobody who cares about his fellow citizens and legal migrants would support the criminal enterprise that the H1-B 'visa' arrangement has been since its inception. There are now thousands of American high-tech personnel who have been thrown out of work by this and other ploys. You and your co-criminals are part of an economic 'race to the bottom' plot, which seeks to bring our living standards down to the horrid 'temporary worker' Chinese and Indian levels.
Jason,  on 05/01/2009 @ 01:37 PM PST  wrote:
Thanks for all the great comments everyone. Great stuff!
terrig,  on 05/31/2009 @ 08:51 PM PST  wrote:
There is no need to rely on the foreign skilled workforce when we have plenty of people with good degrees and knowledge here in America that can't find good jobs, who are left to to sink into mediocrity because their souls are crushed. We do not support our nation's intellectuals, hence the term "brain drain" -- other countries see this and are taking note. That's why we want THEIR skilled workers now, because they KNOW the importance of education and enforce it.
lcanto,  on 07/15/2009 @ 02:17 PM PST  wrote:
Although I understand and agree with your point that skilled laborers that are an asset to the country should have an easier time being retained, I am disappointed on how the country deals with higher education here. I don't beleive that we as a nation embrace those that choose to pursue it. If we did maybe we'd produced more skilled labor!!!
Kurt,  on 07/17/2009 @ 02:24 PM PST  wrote:
This letter rocks!
wesandsue,  on 10/25/2009 @ 01:27 PM PST  wrote:
Sry J. There is a skilled work force right here in America. HR people get incentives and bonuses for saving their companies money. Foreigners are willing to work cheaper and without extras. This is why so many companies want the H-1b ratios increased. It comes down tothe same thing as illeagals the employers hire them to cut down on overhead. I have a friend of mine how worked for D.Shore construction in Charleston SC. There was a mexican worker who hired in as a green helper. 1 month later he quit then 2 weeks later he hired back in as a journyman under a different name and social sec #. Also soc. sec cards and birth certificates are on sale in every state. All you have to do is get here and have enough money to pay for them.
kpug1,  on 01/05/2010 @ 10:42 AM PST  wrote:
I agree with your post Jason however, if more Americans get grants and better education we wouldn't need to rely on immigration. The unemployment rate in the US may turn around if encouragement to better educate oneself is available and offered. Not to be bias or anything but many, not all, immigrants still are having difficulty learning English as a primary language in this country and don't understand it. Which causes problems with communication in the business and co workers nationally and globally. Better education and continued education is available and businesses should encourage it to the workers more so than relying on immigration to do the job and finding cutting expenses when one who is already in the business may benefit from more education.